I was reading a book and it had this arguement for God not existing, that I just can't fault. In sound mind and with much thought, I can't get around it. I'm not attacking theist's beliefs, but can a believer not see how crystal clear this is?:
A God, by definition, is all knowing and omnipotent (can do anything)
So, if God knows everything, he knows EXACTLY how he will intervene in our lives in the future - be it through miracles, or answering prayers etc. He will know every minute detail.
If he already knows exactly what he will do, then he can't change his mind.
He couldn't say, be considering option A, then change his mind to option B - there wouldn't have been an option A in the first place since he would have know what his final decision would be.
If he can't change his mind...then he isn't omnipotent - there is something he can't do.
In which case; A God can't exist. A being that knows all and can do anything, does not work.
What's your opinion on this?
2006-12-25
13:31:39
·
33 answers
·
asked by
Adam L
5