If a choice is allegedly given by a deity, but information is deliberately withheld by said deity, how can that choice be construed as "Free Will?"
If said deity is omniscient, said deity will, of course, know the level of information required for any entity to make a decision regarding this alleged choice, and in choosing what not to reveal is, indeed, making the decision for the person, thus contrary to the concept of "Free Will."
I’d contend, to clarify, that with the deliberate withholding of information by a deity there is a complete absence of free will. If a god expects you to make choices but withholds data, said god, not you, is making the choices....and an omniscient god *knows* this.
2007-06-09
07:55:23
·
13 answers
·
asked by
LabGrrl
7