This Question was inspired by the whinging clown in an earlier Question who believed torture (and other atrocities) were wrong under all circumstances.
Let's face it, warfare is a nasty business. People get caught in the crossfire all the time, and becoming a prisoner just isn't a good way to end up. Not everyone who wants to surrender is received with open arms, and "fight to the death" outcomes are just too common.
When you do pick up prisoners, especially in a counterinsurgency, people get roughed up all the time. This happens. Americans are obsessed with the Laws of Land Warfare, but guaranteed when we roll out with Iraqi security forces and they get to work "questioning", they aren't offering coffee and donuts. Surprise? They get results.
So really, given the realities of a war on the ground, why is it that we get the "Holier than Thou" types from thousands of miles back in the States back-guessing what the troops do? Who are these people?
2007-04-29
09:58:01
·
13 answers
·
asked by
Nat
5