According to the U.S. Court of Appeals in Skoros v. City of New York, which the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear on appeal yesterday, public holiday displays can include a menorah to symbolize Chanukah and the star and crescent to symbolize Ramadan, but cannot include a crèche (nativity scene) because a crèche "is solely a religious symbol," implying that the menorah and star and crescent are not.
The Appeals Court decision praises the display policy for teaching "the lesson of pluralism by showing children the rich cultural diversity of the city in which they live and by encouraging them to show tolerance and respect for traditions other than their own.” That's extremely admirable, but what about Christianity? Isn't it part of the cultural diversity of the city, too? Doesn't it deserve equal respect with these other religious traditions?
Am I the only secularist who feels that the NYC Department of Education, the Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court got this one wrong?
2007-02-21
11:52:57
·
5 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous