A privilege? It's a throwback from Feudal times, an anachronism.
In Uk 12 people are literally plucked off streets and sit in judgement of a person on trial. (exceptions.. SF etc).
They are supposed to be your piers; they are more often nothing like that. Take a successful businessman in the dock in his fine suit and the Jurors, all maybe from poor backgrounds who hate him on sight. Or the black accused with 12 white NF jurors…
Very few people understand Law and whilst it is for them to determine facts and not Law (strictly speaking) few can distinguish between the two.
Unless a person has similar life experiences as you he is not a pier. The US have a good (but often abused) selection process for jurors.
Better I say to have 3 judges, law professors etc who are objective, impartial and know the law.
Trial by jury is not a right it is in my view an ancient ritual which should have been done away with at the same time as ducking stools.
2007-06-24
21:11:30
·
9 answers
·
asked by
kunt
1