I’m not saying he was awful. But I keep reading some people on YA saying he was the “most feared slugger in the game.” I just don’t see it. To reduce park effects and their distortions, let’s look at where he ranked in things like Slugging, OPS+, Runs : Created in his years in the AL.
NTT=Not in the top ten.
1975: Slugging 9, OPS+ and RC NTT.
1976: SLG 2, NTT and NTT.
1977: #1 SLG, #6 OPS+, #2 RC (Behind Rod Carew, a non-slugger)
1978: #1 in all three—kudos.
1979: 2/4/2
1980: 7/NTT/NTT
1981: NTT/NTT/3-way tie for 10
1982: NTT/NTT/NTT
1983: 2/6/6
1984: NTT/NTT/NTT
1985: SAME
1986: 10/6/6
1987/1988/1989: NTT/NTT/NTT
That's good. But that's not feared or dominant more than anyone else of his time.
George Brett led the league more often in slugging percentage. So did Schmidt, Jackson, Yaz, McCovey...he is tied with Fred Lynn.
That doesn't look like #1 dominant guy to me.
2007-11-29
09:02:11
·
7 answers
·
asked by
Bucky
4