I came across this proof from Descartes, and it is interesting, take a look:
1. I think, therefore I am.
2. I cannot be mistaken about the ideas that I have.
3. There can never be more objective reality in the effect (i.e., the idea) than there is formal reality in the cause (i.e., object of the idea).
4. I have an idea of perfection or infinite substance.
5. My idea of perfection is the most objectively real idea that I have.
6. The only possible formal cause of that idea is infinite substance.
Therefore, God must exist.
It is pretty sound from a logical standpoint, and although I know you're not supposed to disagree with Descartes, I think that his fourth step is a fallacy, because it is impossible for the human mind to comprehend infinity, and therefore perfection.
However, I was wondering if anyone knows of a proof mathematical/logical or otherwise of the existence or lack of God(s). Logical answers only please, thanks!
2007-09-24
09:21:08
·
31 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous
in
Religion & Spirituality