Good arguments for each - Hooliday certainly seems to have the edge if you look at the tradtional criteria of great triple crown category numbers. Plus he had a great September. Usisually, if that guy's team makes the playoffs, he's a lock.
Rollins' case is a little more unconventional. The arguments for him include looking at things like 30 HRs and 96 RBI from the leadoff position, his hits & stolen bases & total bases, his leadership, and the fact that he does it all as a great-fielding shortstop.
So who do you give the edge to?
2007-10-04
03:04:08
·
15 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous