So here's the ultimate question, since it seems to be such a big priority in the Muslim world:
Why is alcohol haraam in Islam?
Besides the fact that it's stated in the Quran that wine is haraam, and since we're in the spirit of questioning things here, what is the logical reason for alcohol to be haraam?
A few of the reasons given by people are:
"It makes one lose control" Not entirely true. Alcohol does not make you lose control, an excess of alcohol does. Anger also makes one lose control, yet anger is not illegal in most Muslim countries. Eating too much paracetemol can make one lose control. Lust makes one lose control. Driving fast does too. So why does alcohol get the bad rep?
"Alcohol is hazardous to your health" Again, not entirely true. Yes, an excess of alcohol can lead to many harmful conditions, but a glass of wine a day is commonly believed to be beneficial to your body, due to its rich content of antioxidants. People in many European countries drink a lot more alcohol than people in many Muslim countries do, yet they live longer and healthier lives. But even if we were to say that alcohol is bad for you, why isn't beef haraam? Or ghee? Or fat?
"It alters the state of your mind" So do tobacco, caffeine, and antidepressants, yet these aren't haraam (at least in most circles). The world's most common drug is tea. The Ismaili Hasashin were a pretty important sect in Islam which allowed their soldiers to get high on hashish before a mission (that's where the word "assassin" comes from). Dervish dancers and malangs alter their state of mind by dancing in a frenzy.
Why do people who drink get judged more than people who steal? What exactly is the reason for alcohol to be haraam; what does it solve?
2007-02-08
04:17:00
·
9 answers
·
asked by
tring tring!!
3