Example 1.
3 people standing in the path of an oncoming vehicle. All are hit by vehicle and die.
1st person - doesn't see vehicle coming. Is struck and killed.
2nd person - sees vehicle, doesn't avoid it because believes he will survive somehow and is struck and killed.
3rd person - sees vehicle coming, intentionally stands in the path of vehicle knowing it will kill him. Is struck and killed.
I think most people would agree that 1 was an accident, 2 was just mistaken, while 3 was suicide.
Example 2.
1st person - has cancer but doesn't know it. Dies.
2nd person - has cancer but prefers faith or alternate treatment to modern medical treatment. Dies.
3rd person - has cancer and knows it will kill him but refuses all treatment. Dies.
Question: Did the 3rd person in example 2 also commit suicide?
Opinion: Being passive can't omit suicide as a cause of death as the 3rd person was passive in simply not avoiding the car.
Anyone have an opinion on what defines suicide, method or intent?
2007-11-29
22:09:21
·
5 answers
·
asked by
russj
3
in
Religion & Spirituality