In science, competing theories have to be falsifiable to be valid - There has to be at least one test you can do which has the potential to show that the theory is not consistent with reality, and therefore must be false. Without falsifiability, we have no way of distinguishing between true and false ideas.
So, assuming for the sake of argument that gods could exist, by what method can you distinguish between a real god and a fake one? Clearly faith alone is not enough, because people will always have faith in whatever gods they believe in, regardless of whether they really exist or not.
Let's say that you believe in the Christian god or the Muslim god and your view is that Zeus is just a myth - How can you test this view against reality? If you can't test it, how can you rationally justify dismissing one god and not the other?
2006-07-13
22:07:54
·
14 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous