There is no room in the laws of Physics for choice. When we think we are making a choice, it is true that we could not have chosen any other way.
When you flip a coin, the coin doesn't chose to be heads or tails, it happens becase of the laws of chaos, aerodynamics and conservation of momentum. Subtle changes can effect whether the coin is heads or tails, yes - but the coin never choses. Our brains obey the same laws of physics as the coin - we 'decide' things based on how our brain is hard-wired, which essentially is down to nature and nurture. If that is the case, if I ask you to chose heads or tail, your decision is made in your brain and cannot have been made any other way. The only place choice is allowed is in religion (most religions say that choice is a gift from God, and that our decisions are our own).
Can an atheist believe in choice? If you believe in choice, how can you accept that the physical world is all there is?
2007-02-19
20:42:11
·
11 answers
·
asked by
Mawkish
4