Freud is momentarily downplayed as the rage (and hope) nowdays is neuroscience, that is using fMRI and PET to search for the mind's workings and faults. This conception is a kind of biological reductionism that is reviving in psychology after seeming to have been abandoned. Predictably, it will swing back in few years after the intial enthusiasm wears off and the "great expectations" will be replaced by frustrations. As to psychoanalysis there are many problems with it but the last generation of critics doesn't help sorting out them out. They all seem to agree only on character assassination : Freud was a charlatan and psychoanalysis is a fraud of gigantic proportions. For the rest each as his own pet theory/interpretation to promote. And they do it as cocksure and blind to self criticism as Freud did but they do it while having far less of substance to offer. For MacMillam and Shamasdani it is all suggestion and imagining things [ nevermind that the charge of suggesstion is as unfalsifiable as that of repression : once laid down there is no defense against it since anything working can be explained as working because of suggestion ]. For Borch-Jacobsen it is "mimetism", for Esterson it mixing facts with interpretations, for Crews it is pseudoscience as opposed, perahps, to English literature which is his field of expertise, for Cioffi it is "pseudo-heremeneutics" [whatever this may mean], for Szasz it is all ethics, politics, and religion. Even Sophia Freud has an opinion : it is essentially similar to Mein Kampf. Freud would be overwhelmed to know how many possible meta-interpretations he missed to consider as alternative explanations. However in truth Freud did often overstate his case-- perhaps a necessity if you want to have your points considered at all-- and it now fires back in some good critical points to be made. But none of them warrants the bashing attitude and the "final" conclusions that these new anti-freudian scholars try to promote.
2007-01-13
22:27:53
·
7 answers
·
asked by
Analyst
7
in
Psychology