I'm the book mender at a local library, and a Captain Underpants book came across my bench yesterday. I decided to see what the hype was about and started reading a few pages. I was STUNNED!
I thought people bought books for children to help them learn how to read and spell.... this trash does neither!
Rather than use "their" in a sentence, such as "their powers" the author uses "there". Rather than "able", "abel". When else did a Biblical character make his debut in a secular children's illustrated novel? Tow dramatic errors in four pages of text.
Has the job of editor been eliminated from books for children?
Do authors not care that children learn how to read and write from the trash they spew?
Is there no sense of responsibility when writing for children?
For me, I think this may be the beginning of a crusade for better children's literature. Maybe it's time to start a column critiquing children's books.
It makes sense now why many people have problems spelling.
2006-12-16
05:13:56
·
8 answers
·
asked by
Deirdre H
7