The first, which someone pointed out to me on IIDB: you cannot state that god exists because morals exist. First, there is no objective morality because different cultures approve and disapprove of different things all the time. Second, if objective morality did exist, as many theists posit, are they objectively moral because god said they were good, or are they good without him saying anything? If it is the former, then they are not objective, they are subjective because god said so. If it is the latter, then the morals are independant of god and thus cannot prove his existence.
The second, which I came up with on my own: prayer, which is mandatory in many religions, does not allow the existence of a god. A god must necessarily be omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent to be god; if it does not meet all three criteria then it is not a god. If you are praying about a problem you are facing, this means that the god made the problem or allowed it to exist, and thus it is not
2007-08-01
19:44:16
·
10 answers
·
asked by
Rat
7
in
Religion & Spirituality