I'm sure this is asked all the time, but it's a fun one to rehash. Mine with reasons is:
1B - Lou Gehrig - Awesome hitting ability, and maybe the nicest guy in baseball history.
2B - Joe Morgan - More versatile than Hornsby, Joe could hit for power, stole bases, played better defense than Hornsby too.
SS - Honus Wagner - pretty much a perfect player with no real flaws in his game
3B - Mike Schmidt - Power, speed, on base average, and defense, the only thing he couldn't do was hit for average that well, and he struck out a lot.
RF - Babe Ruth - He's a given
CF - Willie Mays - He's just the most versatile choice at this position over Cobb or Mantle
LF - Ted Williams - Barry Bonds can suck it frankly.
C - Johnny Bench - Defense and power puts him ahead of Berra.
P- Walter Johnson - just ahead of Lefty Grove.
Mgr - John McGraw - kinda reminds me of Billy Martin, but better
DH (Optional) - Rogers Hornsby - IF he could keep from being such an ***.
2007-03-29
02:39:58
·
14 answers
·
asked by
John L
5