As I read Nietzsche and consider history it seems to.
After reading for years and asking many people, I come across basically two arguments for why we should be moral without God:
1. Good people want the world to be a good place, so its good to want the world to be a good place.
2. Consequences, Reward and Punishment, what goes around comes around. If you're good to people they'll be good to you. Cooperation.
These reasons fall apart. The first is just circular logic and doesn't go anywhere. The second is valid most of the time, but people can get away with things and escape this reward and punishment social system with money, power, force, deception. Any student of history can see that.
I read some Kant and Plato and Bible and kin selection and Nietzsche, and the only universally sound reason to be good/moral that convinces me is the idea that one day we will each stand before God to give an account of our lives.
2007-08-31
11:12:50
·
14 answers
·
asked by
spaintola
1