So the Twin Paradox is resolved by the fact it doesn't account for the three frames of reference for the traveler (e.g. the ac/deceleration at the turn). Relativity is not proven wrong (not proven right either, but that's a different issue). Fine.
Several explanations talk about the relativisitic doppler effect. For example, traveler sends a signal (like radar) every year (as measured by traveler). To homebody, it appears to come faster or slower due to doppler effect.
However, the relativistic doppler effect refers to the frequency of the wave (radar), not the frequency at which we turn the radar on and off.
The radar signal would be red or blue shifted, which *would* be determined by the relativistic formula. My claim is the "acoustic", not relativistic, doppler effect should apply to the frequency of messages (frequeny of radar turned on/off).
Agree?
2006-08-08
16:26:40
·
4 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous