I appreciated the kind answers when I asked before, but it seemed most answerers misunderstood my question, maybe because my wording was bad, so I'm rewording it. I know C major has no sharps or flats & is easiest to play, that middle C is 256 Hz, that there must be a standard for instruments to tune to, that many things are just arbitrary & that harmonic, melodic & natural minor scales differ. What I don't know is how C major historically ended up being the key with no black keys. I seem to recall modern major & minor modes were once the ionion & aeolian modes, respectively, of the old church modal system. I wonder if the ionion mode just happened to start on C before it became the most important mode. If so, I could see how the C major scale would be what remains after the other modes went out of use (just a guess, though). But that still wouldn't explain why C major has no black keys, especially since keyboards were developed after the primarily vocal modal medieval period.
2007-06-28
02:18:47
·
6 answers
·
asked by
Eric L
1