why is killing yourself seen as selfish?

Question

isn't it more selfish to expect someone to live under debilitating mental conditions just so YOU, as a society, as the family and friends of loved ones, don't have to deal with the consequences of them killing themselves? it is wrong to put the blame of guilt on a suicidal person, each person's life is their own to live, mess up, or, if the situation calls for it, end, in the way that they desire- and I disagree with anyone- especially those don't lift a single finger to help- who claim it's wrong either regiously or morally. it might be both, but it's still your inalienable choice to make, and that fact should never by clouded by politics, especially at the expense of potential respite. it's a load of political bull, people, open your eyes. you don't have to cave to religious or societal pressures telling you you have to do something so inherently your own decision as live your life.

Answer 1

Hi Vice,
First of all a suggestion....... Take some nice deep breaths, all the way up from your diaphragm, get some good oxygen flowing into that blood stream buddy. It's all-okay. Now, if you need to talk to someone, do it, do or don't tell anyone but find someone to talk to if you need it. It's nothing to be ashamed of EVER, it's not a sign of weakness or being scared but dude, life can be overwhelming at times, it's okay. I too, although not suicidal, suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder due to a series of sever events that happened all within about a two month period, the worst of which was my police partner being killed on the interstate and it taking me 20 minutes to find his unrecognizable body more than 100- feet off of the road in the bushes, holding him in my arms as he sucked in his last breath ever. I held it all inside, all of it from that to everything else that has ever happened in my life. I had to teach myself to be a little selfish. I was always rescuing others but never taking care of me. You have to.
As far as someone telling you how selfish it is to take your own life and ease your pain, trust me, years of training has taught me that these words are nothing more then a back door entrance to someone begging you not to remove yourself from their life because they love you. In your heart of hearts I think you know that. Live your life for you, for your family or future family, for the smile of a child you may have the touch of someone deeply in love with you. As for the depression, damn it hurts and sucks and sometimes there is no possible way to explain it to someone who has never had it. They are entitled to their own thoughts but that is all they are. You know how you feel and so do I. I would talk to you anytime, any day if you needed an ear but I do encourage you to find a person to use as a confidant and release some of this energy that is eating you up. Find your way back to you. There are plenty of people waiting for you to come back, believe me. Be well my friend.

c

Answer 2

Apparently as a whole, we as a society, wait no, we as the human race, are not doing our job, if even one person has to ask why suicide is wrong. Mental illness, depression, anger, it doesnt matter, you can always be helped as long as there is someone there to help. You can not lay all the blame on everybody else though, unless you were born with diminished brain capacity, you are still in charge of your own actions, and if you really want the help, you could ask for it. Not in a little squeaky voice, but out loud, for everyone to hear. You are no less important than anyone else on this planet, and someone better listen to you. You, along with everybody else, deserves to live a happy, fulfilling life, and I emphasize LIFE. So is killing ones self...selfish, yes, not only by the person who did the killing, but by those who didnt notice there was a problem in the first place.

Answer 3

I agree, you are totally right
However there are exceptions to this,
I think if it's done calmly ie by overdose etc then that's fine, but what about when the attempt fails and it takes 3 weeks of medical care before they die,
Or when it's under a train and witnessed by others, or off a building, emergancy services have to pick up the pieces literally,
I saw an accident where a woman was run over by three cars, Now two years on I'm still traumatised,
I wonder how people feel after they've witnessed someone jumping under a train, that decision must affect hundreds of people

Answer 4

It's extremely selfish, especially if you have friends and family that love you and care about you. Up and killing yourself shows that you only think about yourself and your problems with no regard to anyone else or their feelings. Think about the possibility that these family and friends would be more than willing to help you deal with these problems in any way that they can, and still have you around as a friend and relative. Killing yourself is never a rational solution, or a solution at all. Think of the tremendous grief and anguish you would be leaving behind, and you most certainly would, that these ones would experience for years afterwards.

Answer 5

Yes it`s egocentric, you'll break the lives of the ones round you who care approximately you. Maybe you have got to take a look at performing some voluntary paintings with folks who're homeless, or ache in any other manner. If you don`t believe like there's a factor on your existence, MAKE ONE. Helping different folks will supply you a intent and take your brain away out of your possess problems. Also move to the medical professionals and inform them precisely how you're feeling. Keep going again till they support, however you ought to additionally recognize that you simply need to support your self.

Answer 6

Most of the time, suicide is seen as opting for an easy way out...

so if the person was a mother of four who depended on her to be fed...it is inevitably a selfish thing to do..to go for death rather than sticking around for your kids.

Also..people depend on each other, if youre a teenager...you have parents who love you or friends who need you and if youre an adult you probably have family members who would be much worse without you.

So its inevitable that suicide be seen as a selfish act, a final desperation to save urself pain, while inflincting pain on everyone around you with your death.

Not something responsible people do..

if youre in debilitating mental conditions...then youre not thinking right in the first place...so im sure most people...even God can forgive the person doing it.

Answer 7

Killing yourself is the result of someone who only sees their trouble, their struggle , feels only their pain; as i they are the only ones hurting. One of the best ways to be relieved of pain is to help somene elst through theirs. So many people forget that there is a way to lend an ear or help in some other significant way if they could stop foculing on themselves for a little while. They are not the only ones hurting and wanting to escape the pain. Suicide is not the answer when we have so many skills and talents that can make the world a better place for others hurting also.
Suicide is the result of a completely self centered way of thinking.

Answer 8

in this world today, where 'waste' is such a dirty word, the waste of a life is so much worse...... things change on a whim, turn around on a dime, are new in a flash in our lives and it's a horrible waste if a life ends , when maybe tomorrow one of those changes could have made a great difference in that life, ... but they're gone, and they missed it..... wasting a life is a lousy thing ..... there's no way to even guess what good could have come from that life.... even if it's just the ancestor of a good person in a few generations... it's still lost if that life is snuffed out too soon.....

'a mind is a terrible thing to waste'..... so true.... but so is a LIFE..................

Answer 9

killing yourself is seen as selfish because you leave the others to suffer after you are gone.

on the other hand the bible says that there is no greater love than to give ones life for the ones we love.

If I commit suicide by stepping in front of the gunman, knowing I will be shot and die, is it selfish or the greatest love?

Answer 10

I think its selfish because to kill yourself would hurt so many people, like your family and friends who love you. People can be cured from suicidal thoughts so it wouldn't be selfish of your family ect to keep you living with these thoughts until you are cured. I know this doesn't answer the greater question you asked but certainly my opinion to the initial one.