The Golden Rule: Good, but Good Enough?

Question

"Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

The Golden Rule is at the very least a good starting model for your life, but does it also exhibit some flaws? All people are different. Not everyone wants to be treated like another person. You may want someone to give you a horse, but someone else may think getting a horse is actualy bad (they don't want one and they'll have to maintain one). So they don't want you to do to them what you want someone to do to you. So perhaps a better guideline/rule would be to not think what someone else wants (based on yours), but to actualy attain the knowledge of what they want from them, and go from there.

Of course i guess you could also say that the Golden Rule shouldn't be applied to everything (like the horse example) but applied to everyone wants what they want, so do what they want. So it is applied in a vague way rather than a specific way, which makes the statement somewhat confusing.

Answer 1

I agree that you shouldn't take the Golden Rule as a very specific rule, but more of a general rule. Another way of saying the Golden Rule is "Treat others the way you'd like to be treated." This can be a little bit easier to understand apply to your life.

When receiving a gift from someone, you would hope that they would think about your interests or what you would like or what you need, and use that to guide them in getting you a gift. Therefore, when getting a gift for someone else, you should think about their interests and what they want or need, and use that to guide you.

Don't get bogged down in the specific. Look at it as a general guideline. Simply put, you like people to be nice and thoughtful to you, so you should be nice and thoughtful to others. You don't like others to be mean and critical of you, so you shouldn't be mean and critical of others, and so on.

Answer 2

The golden rule is about giving people respect, and they in turn will respect you. It is not about giving 'things' and expecting the same in return - not in physical things, but such things as goodwill, respect, honesty, dignity, etc etc.

A simpler version of it, would be
Harm no one, including yourself.

This would eliminate wars, violence and murder, etc etc.
And so it would be a good thing.
Better than any God or Bible, etc etc.
There is no misunderstanding with this basic fundamental law. After all it is the law of civilisation.
Think of traders wishing to do business with each other. The horse example - as an example of trade. You would not cheat another trader - because he would not do business with you again in the future. And it is continuous trading that has allowed civilisations to live side by side, and to prospher.

Answer 3

properly i think of its a conventional rule, yet that does no longer propose you will possibly desire to enable somebody be impolite to you or handle you with disrespect. Treating others as you elect to be dealt with might desire to be considered once you first initially meet somebody, without judgment, then if the different person treats you badly you have a ideal to retaliate or merely walk away. i've got self assurance incredibly, LOVE is the golden rule, and on an identical time as you do no longer might desire to love incredibly anybody (nor might i decide to propose it), you will possibly desire to be a loving person. that's all we want in this international (incredibly of religion, dogma, and a "me-me-me" attitude).

Answer 4

This rule can't be applied for evrething. It's true !
But in general if you are talking about gifts or so on... you can do that.
Though, the horse can be sold...:)...
So...

Answer 5

no man goes to the father except he go through Jesus.

Answer 6

Good enough for what?