What's different between the US and it's Mexicans and Germany and their Jews?

Question

Wasn't one of Hitler's most known propaganda tactics "they are taking our jobs" and "they have all of our money"?
How is this different from the arguments regarding our illegal Mexican immigrant problem? I know we haven't started killing them yet, but based on some of the hate I've seen written here....and based as well as on some of these moronic militias as far away from the border as Kansas and Nebraska, how far away is eradication? I realize it's a broad question and I will receive some very loving return mail...

BTW what evidence is there that those Jews were legally in Germany? Nobody yet has given a true and comprehensive answer that I didn't address in the question.

God some of you people are ignorant. Do you even read the full question and think of the intent behind it? Some of you've made assumptions about the motivation of this question without even giving it's origin or purpose full consideration. You are the part of the mass Republican party I can't stand and I really am ridiculously conservative.

Answer 1

there are differneces in effect but there ARE BIG SIMILARTIES in so far as the arguments used by Hitler against the jews



dont you love how Anti-s will avoid the real question your asking and they focus just on what they can use to confuse the original question

very manipulative antis

Answer 2

They are not our Mexicans. They are Mexico's Mexicans. We have nothing against OUR hispanic citizens and legal residents. Don't try to make this into a racial issue (like that's never been done before). And we are not in the business of exterminating people. We just want illegals to go home.

Btw---How can they be hard working people and NOT take our jobs? It's not propaganda if it's true. Propaganda is saying that they do jobs we won't do.

If the Jews were not in Germany legally then they should have been deported. But the way we treat illegals, particularly hispanic illegals, is nothing like the way the Jews were treated during the holocaust. I'm sure they would have preferred free education, health care, the privilege of working and owning businesses and homes, government checks, and more protection of their rights than citizens to the treatment they actually received. I am all for rescinding these privileges that illegals receive, though. That will be reason enough for them to self deport. It is not our responsibility to make up to them what their own governments deny them. We have legal ways to come here, and can't afford to take in everyone that wants to be here at one time.

Answer 3

i know i would be hated for this, yet there are similarities and a number of of differences. the diversities are obtrusive, so I won't state them. The similarities are that they've been compelled out of their place of beginning, a land that they think approximately holy and a bite of themselves. Many have been compelled to stay in refugee camps for over 50 years. maximum childrens and teens know not something. there's no working water, electrical energy or good nutrients attainable to those people. they are being compelled to stay in those camps by using fact the arable land, and companies are in Israel or Israel's administration. there is not sufficient room for those hundreds of people. I comprehend why Palestinians are so offended, i don't accept as true with their procedures of attempting to handle it.

Answer 4

Hitler overtook their countries while it is the illegal Mexican aliens who are so determined to take our country over.

There were militia in Kansas and Nebraska before illegal aliens were the issue they are now. They did not form because of illegals, they were already in operation. I'm glad you mention Kansas and am surprised that an illegal supporter like you thinks Kansas is way far from the Mexican border. The governor of Kansas, Kathleen Sebelius, attended the secretive Bilderberg annual meeting in Turkey. She was there with Hillery to discuss the Trans Texas Highway which will go through the center of Kansas. Sebelius attracted national attention in May 2004 by signing a Kansas law granting illegal immigrants a tuition break at the state's public colleges and universities.

Despite keeping her trip a secret, the taxpayers of Kansas paid her travel bill. Needless to say she won't be re-elected

Answer 5

The Jews were not illegal, Hitler wanted systematic genocide, he sold the Germans lies about Jews trying to control the world. He also wanted genocide for Gypsies, Poles and countless others. He was a fascist. Antisemitism has prevailed for thousands of years, based on the lie that the Jews killed Jesus. The Catholic church started that. Some of the worst antisemites are Mexicans, Central Americans and South Americans, and others from Catholic countries. Did you hear of the bombings of Jewish temples and day care centers in Argentina? South America was notorious for letting Nazis in. In Jewish Temples in America, on high holidays, the temples need to be guarded against violence.

Americans today are talking about those who come into this country illegally. Coming here illegally is not a lie. To say we are racist is a lie. No one is talking about murder. To equate one with the other is pure ignorance.

Answer 6

Don't you feel just a little silly comparing people who provide free health care and education along with many other services for NON citizens out of the taxpayers pockets to Hitler? You know well that your comparison is absolutely absurd.

These types of comparison not only do not help your "cause" you are actually increasing the anger towards illegal immigration, rethink your technique.

Answer 7

For one thing, the Jews were legal citizens of Germany. Many of our Mexicans are here illegally. As for the militias in Kansas and Nebraska; the Mexicans are also in KS and NE. Please note: they are here ILLEGALLY. Should a cop in Montana refuse to arrest a criminal from Alabama? I don't think we will ever resort to cooking Mexicans in ovens, but we do need to get a handle on the illegal immigration.

Answer 8

Do you continue to ask these questions on a daily basis just to stir the pot...or do you really not get the difference between the German Military murdering over 6 million human beings and American tax payers objecting to paying the bill for illegally obtaining "free" health care and educational services?

Your question shows a hateful and arrogant disregard for human life...and it shows that you know NOTHING ABOUT THE HISTORY OF JEWS IN GERMANY!! In the time it took you to post this Anti-Semitic drivel...and read our "opinions" on the subject...you could have easily researched your premise and discovered how incredibly uninformed and off-base you sound when asking this question.

SOME of the differences:

The Jews persecuted and murdered in Germany were German citizens.

The Anti-Jewish sentiment in Germany was driven by race hatred...it was NOT an issue of legal citizenship...they were hated based solely on their ethnicity (and the social / economic progress they had achieved in a relatively short period). And, while prejudice exists everywhere (no ethnic group is immune) millions of LEGAL Mexican Americans live comfortably and happily in the US without the fear that they will be lined up and shot...or annihilated by the hundreds in gas chambers. Rhetoric is just rhetoric...genocide is ACTUAL genocide!!

Additionally, in post WW1 Germany...the propaganda you refer to was government led and government sponsored. The backlash against illegal Mexican immigration is largely citizen driven. Sure, there are politicians saying similar things...but only to pacify their constituents. You do remember a few months back that our President tried twice to have immigration laws weakened and allow for a period of amnesty for many illegals currently living on US soil. HOW CAN YOU NOT GRASP THE HUGE DIFFERENCES??????

As for showing you "evidence that those Jews were legally in Germany"...shouldn't you START with VALID premise rather than expect us to verify your suppositions? We are not here to teach you history...and by all accounts you're incorrigible... so why should we bother.

There have been Jews living in Germany for OVER 1600 YEARS!! And, while they didn't share an "equal" status in German society for most of that time...they had enjoyed 80+ years of legal equality prior to Hitler's rise to power.

"Nobody yet has given a true and comprehensive answer"...how can we? We can't truly and comprehensively answer your question when you co-opt and thereby (in the context of your query) invalidate the single most obvious and MASSIVE difference simply by including the statement..."we haven't started killing them yet"!!! It's clear... the only posters who can really "answer" your question are the ones who agree with your position...RIGHT?

The Anti-Semitic and entirely dishonest nature of your question says all we need to know about your analytical capacity and your willingness to stoop to the LOWEST levels...just to try and make a point.

As another poster mentioned...you embarrass yourself (and those who share your sentiment...but don't espouse idiocy in the process) AND do a HUGE disservice to those you purport to care about...every single time you advocate nonsense such as this.

*EDIT*

So...if we don't agree with you we're ignorant...LOL

A quick FYI...it's not the responsibility of the "asked" to ascertain a questions true "origin or purpose"...it's the responsibility of the "asker" to clearly state their question! If a student fails a course...it's their own fault. If 99% of the class fails..it's the teacher's fault!

As for assumptions about your motivation...anyone paying attention (reading your previous questions and responses) doesn't need to assume anything...your position has been clearly spelled out time and again.

The question is YOUR question...and your decision to present a dishonest comparison based on personal bias and a lack of historical knowledge or context is not OUR FAULT...it's yours!

What's "ignorant"is trying to compare the citizenry's desire for law and order...with a despotic governments desire for genocide. Again...DO SOME RESEARCH...rhetoric is just rhetoric...genocide is ACTUAL genocide!!

Oh...and I answered your question directly...dispite the onerous limitation you placed on it. Yet, NOT SURPRISINGLY...you don't address...acknowledge...or try and further a substantive discussion...you only whine about the majority of answers you've received.

Whining about the "ignorance" of others doesn't make your question any more valid...or any less inappropriate.

Answer 9

I find your question offensive. You won't win brownie points by comparing American citizens who want to secure their borders to Nazis who murdered millions of innocent people.

LEGAL immigrants of every race and nationality enter our country from all over the world and they are welcome. The U.S. is the most generous nation on earth when it comes to immigration.We allow in more immigrants than all the nations of the world combined.

Your comparison of Americans to Nazis is odious and you should be ashamed for such an asinine question.

Answer 10

Palease USA is TOO nice. We have the right like any country to protect our country and that includes the borders. Foreigners seem to think money grows on trees here.

Answer 11

Well i think it is a bit of a stretch to say that our situation is comparable to the Holocaust. However, i do appreciate the point you are trying to make. So many people in this country are frustrated with the economy and everything else that it is easy for them to find the largest target which is not "illegal aliens" but in fact "undocumented workers." I wish people wouldn't be so quick to be ignorant, and take the time to research the situation and see that the people who attacked our country on September 11th weren't illegal immigrants but were in fact here LEGALLY....they did not come through the US-Mexican border. US citizens are so spoiled they have little knowledge of how bad it actually is in other parts of the world...most Americans don't know what it is like, or how hard it is to leave your family and the only place you have ever known to go break your back working in a foreign place. If the shoe was on the other foot, if we were born into a 3rd world country, starving, going through civil war, etc and Mexico was the richest country in the world....everyone would be fleeing too. Survival, and the hopes for a better life for your family. Thanks for the thought provoction.