English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

2007-11-13 09:14:32 · 30 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

Come on. Really, who has proof? If you think that god is not real, then proof it

2007-11-13 09:17:44 · update #1

Note: start with the Lord Almighty. Also known as Yahweh. He is mentioned in the Torah and the Bible

2007-11-13 09:22:30 · update #2

If you can't disproof God( Yahweh or the Lord Almighty), Then God exist. If you can't answer, then don't answer.

2007-11-13 09:28:07 · update #3

30 answers

I love how aetheist don't actually answer the question. BECASUE, they can't.

2007-11-13 09:17:25 · answer #1 · answered by JonB 5 · 2 7

I do. I got a congregation of believers together on the top of a 50 storey building a few weeks back. I asked them to pray, all together, that the egg I was going to drop over the side would not hit the ground and that if a god existed, it would interveine.

After an hour of full on prayer, I dropped the egg... spatt! No god!.

Apart from that, there is significant historical evidence suggesting that the idea of god or gods was simply conjecture. An earthquake occured, the shaman prayed to the ground, it stoped. The tribe prayed to the ground everyday and they did not experience another one.

Humans do not like what they can not controll, it scares them, so they attempt to find some meaning and give someone else the responsibility of their safety and mortality.

2007-11-13 17:20:58 · answer #2 · answered by Judo Chop 4 · 2 1

I love how Christians don't answer the question, because they can't!

Oh snap. Ha ha...

There are so many religions in the world, how can they all be right? They all say that each other’s is wrong. If they all say that, then who is right? How do we know any is right? It seems strange.

How do we know God really exsists? In the Bible, he participated with humans; he talked to them, he helped them, he did wonders for them. When was the last time he did this? If he is real, then he must’ve given up on us. When was the last time that he helped “save” his people and parted a sea for them? It seems as if he just lets them suffer now. Why would he let us all suffer? He seemed so open to offer help back then? Why has he ignored us now?

And with science, that proves that the world is 4.6 billion years old? How can you look at the Bible and see that it says the Earth is only a few thousand years old. God created it a few thousand years ago—do you then believe that there were no dinosaurs? Was that all just a story-the actual, physical fossils of these animals are all fake? That science can’t look at them and determined that they are millions of years old? How can you ignore this evidence? Does that mean if you believe in dinosaurs, you don’t believe in God? You wear a diamond on your hand when you marry someone, which is what God wants. Diamonds are millions of years old, which means that they were created before God created the Earth. So, does wearing a diamond ring on your hand go against the belief of God?

If God wanted us to believe in him, why did he give us free will? Why wouldn’t he let it known to us that he does exsist, that he is there for us, that we will go to him when we die? Why must it be so unknown and challenging? What sick person or being would do that-tell you that you must believe in him or perish in hell, but then now let you know he really is there? It’s like some sick joke. I know it’s a “test” and that you must have “faith” in him, but why would he **** people over like that. Why would he make humans have the idea that maybe he doesn’t exsist so that we would believe he doesn’t and punish US for thinking so? Didn’t the Nazi’s tell the Jews that they were going to take a shower, so they believed they were and when they got there, they were gased to death? Doesn’t that seem the same? Trick people into thinking one thing so you can screw them over? Why would God make it so people could die? Why would he let millions of innocent people die a cruel and painful death so they could go to heaven? Why would he let sick and demented people torture these innocent people? Is that a God that shows love and compasion? And then, these people that kill, that torture, that beat these people can ask God for forgiveness and he will grant it to them and let them walk into heaven with these other people they hurt. What kind of God would tell people not to do something and when they do it, he forgives them. Why even follow the rules? Why not just kill people and then ask for his forgiveness? Why not steal and cheat and worship others and then ask for his forgiveness. Tell me?

2007-11-13 17:19:44 · answer #3 · answered by Kelly M 4 · 1 1

No one does, you cannot prove a negative. Funny thing is you cant prove the positive of this one either....

Addendum:
"If you can't disproof God( Yahweh or the Lord Almighty), Then God exist. If you can't answer, then don't answer."
You cannot disprove that invisible dragons reside on the dark side of Pluto. Then they exist?
The burden of proof rests on the one making the positive assertion.

2007-11-13 17:18:17 · answer #4 · answered by Dashes 6 · 1 2

Tell me of which God you speak, then perhaps we can talk about it.

Using a general term like "god" only muddies the issue. Say Yahweh or Jesus if that's what you mean.

That being said, one cannot disprove something for which there is no evidence either way. For example, you cannot disprove that there exists a teacup in orbit around the sun beyond Jupiter, but you likely don't believe that to be true.

2007-11-13 17:19:34 · answer #5 · answered by QED 5 · 0 2

I don't have any physical proof that god does not exist any more than anyone has physical proof that he does.

However, I am so confident in MY own belief that god does not exist that I don't feel the need to qualify MY belief by constantly seeking reassurance in MY belief by asking people to prove MY belief wrong.

You either believe or you don't. That's it no ifs or buts, no need to justify yourself to anyone else just believe what you believe and get on with it.

2007-11-13 17:24:12 · answer #6 · answered by steve 7 · 0 1

I wonder if there is a god then wouldnt he get bored of the same argument over and over. It would really help if he could put up a big sign in the sky one day saying 'I exist' or something.. Then at least everyone would know.
Until that day.. I shall reserve judgement.

2007-11-13 17:30:03 · answer #7 · answered by Rock My Socks 3 · 0 1

Honestly if you can't see the disconnect in logic of your question I don't think we can discuss anything on an equal level.
===
"If you can't disproof God( Yahweh or the Lord Almighty), Then God exist. If you can't answer, then don't answer."

Prove that I don't have your soul in a box in my basement.
You can't, so therefore I have it and I'm selling it to Satan.

Prove that I'm not selling it. You can't, so it's sold and you're going to hell.

Prove you're not going to hell. You can't, so pack your bags.

Do you see now?

2007-11-13 17:18:42 · answer #8 · answered by Demetri w 4 · 1 2

The proof is self evident. Such as I don't have to prove the sky is blue it simply is. God simply isn't here using my five senses I can not detect even the possibility of any god.

2007-11-13 17:29:46 · answer #9 · answered by deztructshun 3 · 0 1

As a man-made creation, there is overwhelming proof for its non-existence.

There is no proof whatsoever for its existence. Except in the minds of the gullible, ill-educated or closed-minded.

2007-11-13 17:18:08 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 0 2

It is right there next to the proof that Santa, the tooth fairy and Zeus do not exist.


Edit:

So, with no proof that they do not exist, you believe in mermaids, dragons, unicorns, leprechauns, elves, etc.

Come on, prove that they do not exist, or admit that they are real.


Or you could admit that you have no freaking idea about what you are claiming.

2007-11-13 17:18:51 · answer #11 · answered by Simon T 7 · 2 2

fedest.com, questions and answers