Question to atheists, evolutionist and every one who wants to answer?

Question

if we take a frog and put it in a blender ( i know it sounds cruel, i would never do that) so we got a frog soup i guess, then we put this mixture in sun and wait a million years, what do we get? do we get a frog? or it remains the same mixture? or what?

Answer 1

"First, you would not create primordial soup that way. Complex organisms like frogs do not come from primordial soup without many intermediate stages. Very simplistic organic life, amino acids, do. It's difficult to predict what will arise from microscopic organisms if anything. It took billions of years before oxygen breathing bacteria ever arrived on the scene"

Nicely put, not a shred of evidence, but nice delivery. Ever wonder why there are no intermediate stages for any creature alive or extinct found amongst the vast fossil record? If you were referring to the Miller experiment in the 50s, where he supposedly simulated life forming, it was discredited by scientists a long time ago. I guess the evolutionists missed the memo.

Answer 2

Well,suppose you keep this mixture in a laboratory,then bacterias will grow in it.And if we believe in Evolution then these bacterias may evolve into Frogs or Frog like creatures after billions of years..Evolution never follows the same path.So chances are that,we may not get exactly Frog like creatures from this mixture.But to make things interesting we can put this mixture(with bacterias) in a planet like Mars where it will get no interference during the course of evolution.Then we can know for sure whether Evolution really is a fact or not.

Answer 3

i hear what you're saying. no, you don't get a frog. i assume you don't want to hear about how existing life will assimilate your frog soup in a matter of days. if the mixture is homogenous, nothing will happen. i just hope this is not where you tell me that the origin of life is just like that frog soup.

Answer 4

No.....you see, evolution works on LIVING organisms. And since that frog is very much dead, it will not evolve.
What you would get after a million years would be a blender containing, well, dirt, i guess, since organic matter (eg the blended frog), as you know, decomposes.

Answer 5

First, you would not create primordial soup that way. Complex organisms like frogs do not come from primordial soup without many intermediate stages. Very simplistic organic life, amino acids, do. It's difficult to predict what will arise from microscopic organisms if anything. It took billions of years before oxygen breathing bacteria ever arrived on the scene.

Answer 6

You get dried up sludge in a million year of blender.

I assume you are trying to make a meaningless comment on abiogenesis. Your volume is tiny, your timescale is short, you've insulated the system from lightning, and your specimen is not even sterile.

Answer 7

Most atheists and agnostics operate on logic. To the best of their ability they reason out the world around them. There's no point trying to disprove their point of view with an argument that's without logic.

Answer 8

:) Unhappy frog, dead frog, blended frog, space-shipped frog, vaporized frog. Then a long wait. Then a doh! moment; the frog is long gone.

Answer 9

If you take a glass of water from a jug - return it & take another glass full, you will not get the same molecules, but still a glass of water.

The point being, what are you hoping for with this question?

.

Answer 10

You wouldn't have to wait a million years, the frog slime would instantly vaporize.