Why do atheists keep linking Christianity and crime?

Question

They never cite any sources. I think it's common sense that practicing Christians do not go in much for armed robbery and narcotics trafficcing. I'm sure most criminals are quite without religion,whatever show they might put on for parole boards (or,in some instances,sincerely convert while incarcerated). I keep seeing these postings claiming "most criminals are Christians". Were did atheists get this strange notion?

You people sound like you're mentally ill. People are asked their religion when they enter prison and they usually claim a Christian denomination? Well,i would suppose so,since playing the good Christian involved privileges and looks great to a parole board. Aren't you perverting you're statistics? These are polls of prisoners,not parishinors. You seriously beleive that if you could do a background check on devout Catholics or Lutherans most would have a record of imprisonment? You people are out of your minds. This is like saying,if most violent crime is committed by blacks then most blacks commit violent crime. Even assuming sincerity on the part of inmates obviously most Christians do not commit crime,certainly not active Christians. By the way,how do they get crime in Demark and Holland if Christianity causes crime?

Answer 1

They are talking about polls of prison populations; they almost all claim to be or were brought up as fundamentalists. Then the atheists take these figures - 99% or whatever - to create the impression that 99% of enrolled,practicing Christians - Catholic,Lutheran,whatever - are supposedly criminals. obviously,criminals do not go to church. It isn't that they're insane or stupid,they're just trying to do some truly cheesy propaganda,and they're not doing a very good job of it. Try to imagine a smack dealer or pimp who races off to mass every day! It's utterly ridiculous. Though that Marrkyy guy has some reaaaaalllllly dumb friends. He just did a posting where one of them asks: How many Buddhists are there in prisons in America? Duh - are there a lot of Buddhists in America generally. He's this guy from Holland who's on a mission to "convert' Americans to Scandinavian-style atheism which he sees as the source from which all blessings flow. He's got quite a troop too - sickening the way they fawn over him - "over Marky you have such panach" - I mean,it's hilarious. But back to the question,no,they don't really believe that. They know they're using those stats in a patently false way. Doesn't matter,since nobody's dumb enough to fall for it.

Answer 2

Christianity as a religion has also a lot of crimes committted even in the past. But those who committed these crimes are demon infiltrators to the churches. Similarly, in the case of the perostraika in Russia, the first white foreigners who went on crusade there were the religious group, the educators-the good groups. Then they were followed by the bad elements like gamblers, prostitutes, syndicates, smugglers, etc. That is also true to Christiantiy where all its members are not real christians but are actually demons incarnate. Superficially, people who are unaware of these infiltrating strategy of satan see the good christians are doing and involved in these crimes. But the truth are the bad eggs are the ones doing them. That is also true to any organization where the rotten elements are the ones that contaminate the good ones and they are the ones who are the criminals inside an organization having infiltrated them.

Answer 3

Somebody the other day found Department of Justice stats saying that only 0.2% of inmates profess atheism.

Any discussion of this will be muddied by the lack of reliability of polls of religions given a small sample size (less than 200 incarcerated atheists in the country), the lack of breakdown according to violent and nonviolent crime, and the conflation (on the part of Christians) of atheism as a philosophical stance and "weak" atheism as simply a lack of religion (though nearly all prisoners at least profess a religion), plus the fact that the last guy to post about this claimed those who left the religion box blank on their surveys were atheists.


Essentially, though, when an atheist points out how religion brings about hate, the argument is separate from the argument that religion is wrong. One should accept or reject a belief on the belief's merits, not usually just because of the consequences of the belief.

Many of us (atheists) do want to argue that there are good reasons religion should be argued against rather than simply tolerated.


Also, it should be noted that any statements about religion and crime are inferences from statistics, while it is easy to demonstrate less criminal hate caused directly by religion.

Answer 4

that's an previous and drained arguement. this is genuine that Europeans as an entire, and the so-reported as Low worldwide places besides, have a decrease violent crime value than the US, yet that's no longer by using fact of our religious majority. interior the 50's they did a learn that each and all the toddlers in Juvinile Halls examine comedian books, so comedian books ought to reason crime! They did no longer see that all and sundry youngsters examine comedian books (it replaced into the 50's, that's what they did). interior the 20's and the 70's they did an identical with adults, and located that there replaced right into a bigger element of black human beings in reformatory than they have been interior the customary inhabitants, so blacks must be RACIALLY stimulated to crime! interior the tip, the single and in basic terms determinate in direction of crime value is poverty ranges. we've very severe ranges of poverty in this u . s . a ., which reasons extra beneficial desperation and the crime value is going up. the variety one thank you to diminish crime is to grant human beings solid jobs, and that's been shown repeatedly. Why do you think of between the standards for somebody on parole is to have a job? In Holland and Denmark, they have a much extra wealthy and better (share sensible) midsection classification, so their crime value may be expected to be decrease. they have unfastened scientific care and robust unions, which leads to a solid midsection classification and much less poverty. much less poverty ends up in much less violent crime, continuously and everywhere. It has no longer something to do with faith, it has each little thing to do with living standards.

Answer 5

People link Christianity and crime because some Christians link Christianity with morals and decency. Some Christians try to claim a monopoly on morality, and the statistics on crime prove them wrong.

Answer 6

Ouch, angafeabeta completely screwed your world up. An FBI analyst showed that atheists make up less than one quarter of a percent of the prison population, but Christians make up over 80 percent. That's got to suck for you. Practicing Christians, according to you, "do not go in much for armed robbery and narcotics traffic(k)ing." Even if you are right, which you aren't, they do go in for chid molestation and rape, murder, and fraud, including embezzlement.

Answer 7

Because they lump all christians into one category. They think that everyone that calls themselves a christian really is. They do not seem to understand that there are many people who say they are christian who obviously have no idea what christianity is. Therefore apparently us "true" christians have to be blamed for everything that some moron does in the name of God when it totally goes against our beliefs.

Answer 8

Most people in prison claim to be Christian.

Answer 9

The reason that link is made, is because most people are half-heartedly raised Christian. When asked what religion they belong to, that's what most answer.

Answer 10

Here's a good one:

http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/2005/2005-11.html