Does the Bible say that God cannot do the logically possible nor that which is against His nature?

Question

For quite some time, the (in)famous question,
"Can God make a rock so heavy that even He cannot lift?"
has been asked.

To combat this question, most people say that God cannot do the logically impossible and/or God cannot violate His own nature.

However, when I read verses, such as Matthew 19:26, Mark 10:27, Luke 18:27, Luke 1:37, Job 42:2, and Jeremiah 32:27, I receive the impression that God can do everything, all things, and anything.

I do not see nor deduce from the aforementioned verses that God can do everything, all things, and anything, except the logically impossible and/or anything against His nature.

In regards to my question, allow me to be more specific; Does the Bible say, indirectly and/or directly, that God can do everything, all things, and anything, except the logically impossible and/or anything against His nature?

Thanks for your time.
Sorry if it was too long.

To TeeM,

If the verses that say "all things are possible with God" refers to salvation, why would Christ use the words "all things"?

To me, I think if He decided to say that salvation was possible with God He would have said," With man this ( i.e. salvation ) is impossible, but with God this ( not all ) is possible."

I appreciate your input regarding the verses of Christ speaking to the rich young man, but what about the other verses, or even Mark 14:36?

Answer 1

You are dealing with human reasoning.

When the bible says 'all things are possible with God' the context clarifies that it is dealing with salvation of man.

Titus 1:2, states that 'it is impossible for God to lie'

Since the bible says Jehovah is all powerful, almighty, and all wise,

He has no reason to try to live by your what if.

Only a fool would try to waste time doing something that has no value.

Answer 2

God is GOD! He is all. He is everything. Think about your hand look at it think what it took to make it the desk you sit at the plants out side the air you breathe the planet you are on then rethink the question again.If he can make the universe , he can do any and all. We can not even comprehend it all .Just imagine the mind.You can't .I can't. We can't even put it it in to scope. We don't have that capacity or intelligence.Just because we don't understand or see the reason why or understand how come or see the simple what we think should be the outcome or solution doesn't mean that ,that is God's reason or method or that he doesn't have something already planned .

Answer 3

God is God...he is the creator of universe. I think he can make a rock heavy, because he is God no law can stop him he can alter them at will. Just think of him as the most Omnipotent being, in reality. Talk to a Priest or someone that is in religion 4 help

Answer 4

Here is the thing, you say god is perfect, all knowing, and all powerful. If god was all knowing why did he create Satan knowing he would go and create evil/hell? If god was all powerful could he create a rock he couldn't lift and if he couldn't is he truely all powerful? If he could then is he truely all powerful?

It's another way of proving what is said about this god creature isn't true.

Answer 5

solid and undesirable are relative concepts. Technically, if God have been to do some thing, it may desire to be the two solid AND undesirable. it would only be a count number of who became perceiving the action. yet another undertaking to contemplate is this. Sin, in the Christian experience, is an act against God. meaning that something God does is, probably, no longer a sin through fact the perception may be that God would not against Itself. for this reason, if God does some thing this is named a sin (which comprise killing the firstborn sons of each and every kinfolk in a area, or destroying the international) one has to bear in mind that it truly is barely a sin if a HUMAN (or technically any sentient creation of God, which comprise an Angel) performs suggested action against Gods will. in the Christian version of issues, think of of God as having the copywright to the universe. God can regulate the universe any way It sees extra healthful and any attempt by way of every person else to do an identical in contradiction to God's will is violating the copywright. yet another undertaking to contemplate is that, later in the Bible, (do no longer ask for a quote, i'm no longer a Christian Theologist) it truly is declared that God would not work together with the international. if truth be told, some human beings have theorized that God's "days" are plenty longer than our very own and that we live in the seventh "day", the day God took to take a seat back. issues like hurricanes are organic activities that are area of the international. The simulation application keeps working even however the universal consumer isn't entering instructions. issues like Grandma's valuable surgical operation are in common terms products of skillful applications of the loose Will granted to Humanity by way of God and for this reason, additionally area of the grand scheme of issues. Grandma's surgical operation is barely a miracle in the experience that each and every thing that takes place in the parameters of the universe are area of one great miracle, the miracle of creation. to this point as feeling sorry for somebody. Feeling sorry for somebody is an act of compassion. to this point as i'm conscious, compassion is a distinctive function that Christians attempt to sell (even with their being Human and for this reason improper and making blunders only like everybody else.). As such, feeling sorrow on the afflictions of yet another, whether this disease is led to by way of God or no longer, may be a favorable undertaking. only my humble opinion. desire it facilitates by way of providing you with yet another PoV --Steele

Answer 6

No that's silly. God can do anything. He just would not waste something as precious as time on a useless miracle.

"Three things come not back, the spent arrow, the spoken word and time wasted."

Answer 7

In your own mind god can do anything since god is your brain so whatever you can imagine is possible---I said what you said in far lesser word.

Answer 8

Is this suppose to be some kind of trick question? GOD can do anything but FAIL.

Francine

Answer 9

Do not talk to a priest, Jesus condemned priest, we have but one teacher and that is God, the Father, who art in heaven. ask God not men.

Answer 10

no