Is this Buddhist koan the explanation to the R&S dynamics?

Question

What does this story mean to you, in the context of your belief system?

A young and studious monk went his teacher and said, "Teach me all about the Buddha nature." His teacher pushed him on the ground. The next day the student returned to his teacher, saying, "I am wiser today than yesterday. Teach me about the Buddha nature." The teacher clobbered him again.

This went on for days until finally the young student could stand it no more. He tearfully left the monastery and went back to his temple at home. There he told the chief monk what had happened. The chief monk said, "You are really stupid! That monk was kinder to you than a grandmother!"

The young student went back to the monastery, and found his teacher. He threw the teacher on the ground. His teacher got up and said, "Now I will teach you about the Buddha nature."

Answer 1

I don't get it.

Answer 2

I think it means when there is an action, there is always a reaction. It is similar to scientific Newton's Third Law.
This way we need to be aware of our action and responsibility.
When the monk teacher at the monastery physically hurt the young monk, there should be a consequence of that action. The monk teacher should receive similar physical act. I don't think it has to be a pay back by the young monk necessarily. Actually Buddha did not teach to hurt the person back or kill that person in revenge, because it would be against the first rule of Buddhism (be kind and not hurting and harming any living things). But at the end, the bad person will receive bad Karma and likely bad things will happen to him/her either in this life or next.
So this is not completely a good story, because it emphasizes short term action and reaction too much. But it sounds dramatic and may teach something about action and reaction.
Good luck.

Answer 3

No. I don't think that this describes the R&S dynamics.

I think that the purpose of the story is to demonstrate that no one can TELL you what Buddhism is. Buddhism isn't explanations. It's just being your real self. That's why practioners do zazen.

The religion and spirituality Q&A is all about explanations of Buddhism.
A story that would demonstrate the dynamics of R&S would be a bunch of people, sitting in a room, talking about Buddhism. Quite a difference from the original story.

Answer 4

whilst one dies in this earth, that's between the 11 sense-Spheres, the physique (Rupa, actual, form, count) will decay and the final ideas (understanding, Cittta, Vinnaya, or Mano) in this Sphere will vanish. the recent ideas will right this moment upward push up in the recent physique and in the recent Sphere--without the ideas, an egg and a sperm won't be able to grow to be a existence. this may well be a Rebirth and there are infinite of them previous to the present existence. Feeling (Sensation, Vedana), memory (Cognition, Sanna), and psychological formations (Volition, Sankhara) are the the rest 3 of Skahndas (5 Aggregates) and are all Cetasikas, which constantly upward push up and polish with Minds. Q- yet, how is it incredibly that I incredibly have lived thousands of lives, whether that is not "me"? A- in accordance to the real actuality of Nature (4 Noble Truths), there isn't any you or me, yet basically Rupa and Nama (Citta and Cetasika) quickly collect at the same time. The ideas is in a persevering with state of flux (Anicca) that looks and disappears straight away on the fee of one trillion circumstances in a single 2d. A single ideas may well be in comparison with one molecule of H2O in a flow of the river. on the time of Rebirth, the recent ideas will right this moment upward push up in the recent physique and in the recent sphere. whilst one continues to be alive, the ideas will upward push up and polish in the comparable physique till the subsequent rebirth. this might ensue for thousands of lives or constantly till the ideas is Enlightened (Nibbana, Nirvana), then there'll be not greater rebirth. Q- If that is not "me"? What DOES flow on from one existence to the subsequent whether that is not area of who i'm top now? A- that is not you that flow from one existence to next. that's the ideas (Citta). for the reason which you do not understand the Noble Truths (lack of expertise), you think of that those physique and ideas belong to you (Attachment, Clinging) and which you're born and die. We desire to call Rebirth (new physique and new ideas) extremely than Reincarnation (new physique however the comparable Soul). Please study the fewer than hyperlink for added expertise.