Is three month salary too much for an engagement ring?

Question

America it's 2 month salary. In Japan, it's three month salary. I figure these are high standards set by jewlery companies not many people follow. It should be what the couple feels is good. But none the less, my girlfriend (who is Japanese) says three month salary should be our price range. I make 300,000 yen a month or about 2500 dollars. I don't want to be seen as stingy.

Answer 1

I think that those sorts of 'rules' are made by the jewelers and are meant to target selfish, materialistic lovers. If your girlfriend is so shallow, you had better get to spending! Personally, I don't even have a ring. I didn't want one! I'm only getting a wedding band because my partner wants us to have wedding bands. I'm not sure if I'll actually wear it all the time though.

Answer 2

I've been reading some other answers to this questions and I just had to put in my own two cents.

I'm not engaged or married but I do have a promise ring with my boyfriend of 3 years. The ring was about 1500 and I thought that was fair considering our time together (we'd together for less than a year and a half). But not that it's been twice that long, I do want something bigger but he says I should just wait a year or two for his to propose (we're both still young). We've looked around at rings and I'm usually looked at the $10,000 range which he thinks is quite feasible.

Then I got to thinking after reading this questions about all the money my boyfriend has spent on jewelry for me and it's been about $3000 after my current ring. That makes me think that if my boyfriend can afford to buy this much worth of jewelry then you can surely afford to buy you future wife a 3 month salary ring. My boyfriend is a busy engineering student who only works during the summer and you're a full grown man with a full time career (I'm assuming).


NO HIS PARENTS ARENT PAYING FOR ANYTHING NOR ARE MINE.

EDIT: I asked my bf too, and he said 4-5 months is good. (That's on a 80-100K salary).

Answer 3

i personally think two months salary is too much. you need to worry about your future marriage, where you're going to live, how to pay your bills, and how to raise your family. Your time together is going to be worth more in the end than some ring or even a fancy wedding ceremony.
i'm a woman, and my husband gave me an engagement ring that belonged to his great grandmother. I don't know how much money it was worth, but it was sentimental.
Most women don't feel the same as me though, and the size ring you buy her may be very important to her as a sign of future wealth you may acquire.
Good Luck because i really think you will need it.

Answer 4

Your gf should not even know how much her ring costs! You should pick out a ring that "mimics her beauty"...a ring that you want to put on the hand of your new bride-to-be... and she should be grateful...not want the receipt! If you get a great deal on a ring that's awesome- why should you go more than you can afford when you could use that money to begin your "marital savings?"
The reason I say this is because my husband-to-be couldn't afford even close to what a "real ring"costs. He got me a beautiful ring he could afford and placed it on my hand...then when we married he placed the slim gold band on my finger at the same moment we became husband and wife. He has since bought me jewelery worth ALOT of money ; but I will always wear the one that symbolizes us...not the one that cost the most!

Answer 5

I paid less than $2500 and my girlfriend was very happy with the ring. Unless you are very well off financially I certainly would not pay $7500 for a ring unless you are Kobe Bryant.
Don't fall for the 2 or 3 month rule; that's strictly marketing.
Your girlfriend is unreasonable; why start off your engagement in debt.

Answer 6

The "months of salary" thing is just garbage - it is just marketing hype and I wish people would stop believing it! Just spend what fits within your budget comfortably, don't go into debt over a ring. The average price for an engagement ring is 800. Just choose something you think she might like.

Answer 7

In the UK it's one month, so basically that rule is a load of rubbish, personally if my b/f spent 3 months salary on a ring I would be a bit shocked, that's a lot of money!!! It's not the value of the ring, it's the sentiment

Answer 8

i'm getting married next October and characteristic multiple wedding ceremony etiquette books. i'm able to't locate the "3 months gross revenues rule" in any of them. the only position i'm able to looking that's on jeweler web pages "advising" you the way a lot to spend on your ring. We truly did not spend 3 months gross revenues on my ring. that ought to were close to to $20k! it really is nuts for somewhat of jewellery, quite in this monetary device. And we do not even own a house yet (we stay in San Francisco - it is going to likely be a lengthy time period before we may have the funds for to purchase a house right here!). My ring is attractive and that i like it. It value us someplace between a million-a million.5 months gross revenues and that is precisely what i needed. in case you own a house, are thoroughly debt loose, and characteristic sufficient liquid sources to the position spending 3 months gross revenues on a hoop is a wise decision... bypass for it. yet, i don't think of that is needed or maybe smart in this monetary device. in case you experience like you'll have a huge diamond ring - purchase one you may have the funds for from an section that permits you to improve at a later date. Then, at the same time as the monetary device rebounds, you may improve your diamond for an anniversary. :)

Answer 9

I think you're absolutely correct on all accounts. There is no way I would ever pay even two months salary for a ring.

Answer 10

She should just be happy you ask her. If she really wants to make you spend 3 months salary that's a bad sign. It should be your option on how much to spend. In my experience these girls that demand a particular ring or amount spent on them are just trouble.