Was Theodre Kaufmann right?

Question

He was a manhattan based Jewish writer who wrote "Germany must perish" in 1941 -he explained that, like Amalek , the German race should be annihilated and forcibly sterilised because of what it was doing - Author's introduction
"This dynamic volume outlines a comprehensive plan for the extinction of the German nation and the total eradication from the earth, of all her people. Also contained herein is a map illustrating the possible territorial dissection of Germany and the apportionment of her lands."- yet he was ignored by anti-semitic allied governements

A review in the weekly Time magazine, March 24, 1941, called Kaufman's plan a "sensational idea."

Answer 1

Not only was Theodre Kaufman not right, he was a madman. Are you attempting to support a position to be held from 1941, or you're just sensationalizing on the fact that a Jewish writer also had some similar thoughts to what the Nazis held against Jews. It was a time of intolerance, a time of scapegoating, a time of name calling. We should all be happy that it ended with his few lives lost as it did. Imagine the cesspool that society would be on the Nazis won the war or, if people like Mr. Kaufmann were actually allowed to propagate their hate.

Answer 2

If only he could have searched beyond national divisions, and applied 'Holy Roman Empire' or 'Babylon The Great' to his thoughts…so close but once again the obvious was overlooked.

Answer 3

Was Kaufmann a Nazi? He sure sounds like one. Collective punishment, forced sterilization...yep, sure sounds like it.

Answer 4

Genocide is a bad idea, regardless of who's behind it.

Answer 5

You seem disappointed.

You do realise that his sentiments prove that he was no better than Hitler, right?

Answer 6

GO KAUFMANN!!