Do You Think That It Is Right For Parents To Spank Thier Children?

Question

This is a tough one......Well, to be particularly fair, we live in a generation where we have technology and greater understanding in sciences like psychology, so I don't think that inflicting pain on anyone will help their disposition in any way, it may even just make them immune to pain, and wreckless.

To add clarity to the question, children do ask questions all the time, and are known for it, I think if parents would spend more time passing on good vibes to kids they wouldnt be bad at all. And spanking is really for lazy people who have been abused, and believe abuse sets one free. Yes, I was spanked all the time as a kid, and no do not have ill feelings toward my parents, however, you don't fight bad behavior with pain treatment. Bad behavior is psychological and not physical.....Duh!

Answer 1

No! It is not right for parents to spank their children!

1) It only has immediate effects and does not teach the child from right or wrong in the long run.

2) Children learn by example, love & discipline and yes, it takes time and patience. Unfortunately, some of us don't have that b/c some parents have to work (not necessarily that they are lazy) or they were never taught that way.

3. Children will make mistakes b/c guess what? They're children! They will make mistakes no matter what so why not discipline lovingly & firmly?

4. Learning that a stove is hot after you touch it is NOT a correct analogy b/c when you touch a hot stove it is inadvertently done. Would you ever teach your child that the stove is hot by leading her to it intentionally? That would be analogous to spanking.

5. When you spank a child, that child learns FEAR, which is not to be construed as respect.

It is more difficult nowadays to raise a child b/c we have to be smarter and use our mental abilities. This is more difficult then the "good old days" of just hitting them & getting it over with.

Children are human beings and deserve respect and love as well as positive discipline.

Answer 2

I feel that spankings at the backside are warranted while you quite have exhausted all efforts to speak with the youngster and they're being TRULY unreasonable, equivalent to throwing a kicking screaming mood tantrum and can NOT concentrate or reply to you. Used to get their awareness, NOT to inflict ache or pain, a few spankings can also be critical. I additionally suppose that for infants, a few matters deserve a smack at the hand mixed with "no" considering the fact that they do not comprehend the phrase NO by myself, equivalent to whilst they are trying to play with the electric outlet or some thing real harmful that you just cannot take the risk of speakme it out. I realize my children have got well swats to the toosh the primary few occasions they have ran out into the streets, two-three occasions every cured them of that truly quick, they do NOT run into the streets in any respect. There are a few matters that children have got to partner with a terrible reaction considering the fact that you without difficulty do not need the time or luxurious of "reasoning" and their instant security will have to dictate the ones situations. The secret's to have a optimistic field process in position that you've got suggestion out and to have each mothers and fathers at the equal web page, equipped to implement penalties whilst critical and stick it out via the alligator tears. Once children make the relationship among intent and final result, they observe who's accountable and spankings can also be have shyed away from, probably removed by means of age five if performed proper.

Answer 3

Spanking is not harmful and it often is the only way a child learns that his behavior is unacceptable. God teaches in his word that we need to discipline our children not out of anger but love. I don't advocate it's only use but I believe if other methods fail spanking will work. Some conservatives will say spanking teaches violence. News Flash: I got spankings until I was 16 and I am an Ordained Minister and never been to jail, prison or charged with a crime. I went to school got fairly good grades and then to college. If my mother was alive today even at the age of 45 if I got out of line she would slap the mess out of me. No discipline done in love carries alot of weight.

Answer 4

Yes, I do as long as it's used properly it's very beneficial. It's one of the few ways to get children to actually learn a lesson quickly. For example when a child touches a hot stove they get burned, feel pain and learn to keep away from the stove inherently. Spanking and the later threats to spank, follow the same principle and have the same pyschological effect on the child.

Also when comparing children who've been spanked to those who haven't, in my experience mentoring, mediating, working with and babysititng children, there is a profound difference. Children who have been spanked are less spoiled, take directions and orders better and are more respectful to adults than those who don't, because they haven't had the chance to run all over mommy. Also this trend continues on into adolescence and on.

As far as the immune to pain and wreckless I think it's the opposite, they learn to fear pain and that pain comes from bad actions and decisions while children who aren't spanked haven't felt much pain and usually seem to think that they can get whatever they want.

I'm not saying there aren't other ways of discplining children, but spanking is one of the most effective ones. On a sidenote, only in America is the nospanking thing a big deal, everywhere else it's completely accepted and the normal behavior (as explained by my foreign friends in college who don't understand the stigma attatched to spanking.)

Answer 5

I think that it depends. My kids have gotten spanked before. I don't use it as the first method of behavior correction. They rarely get spankings, but it is effective when called for. I NEVER use a paddle, belt or anything like that. Just a simple swat of my hand on their rump and they know I mean business. My kids definately aren't immune to pain or wreckless. They are very well behaved and I believe that it is because I am consistant with them and they know there are concequences for their actions whether it may be getting grounded, having a time out, extra chores or a spanking.

Answer 6

Were you spanked? My butt was beat with a rubber shoe anytime I did anything wrong. I feel pain and no harsh feelings towards my parents. I fully believe that knowing the shoe was there kept me from doing things that I knew was wrong. As a child groundings would not work and I didn't get an allowance to garnish. Time out was a joke. I think that because my parents spanked me I am a better person. I will spank my daughter and future children because I believe that this form of punishment works. I also plan to never have cable TV or alot of video games, it makes kids lazy and adopt unhealthy habits of sedentary lifestyle. Does that make me a bad parent? I doubt it. And spanking my daughter won't make me one either.

Answer 7

There are many other ways to tell kids what they have done is wrong. For example, taking things away from them; toys, tv, not letting them go out with their friends to play or whatever. I do not think you need to force PAIN on them to teach them a lesson. Taking something away can put fear in them from getting that something taken away. But on the other hand, being spanked CAN make the child scared of certain people/adults. That's just my opinion and everyone has one.

Answer 8

I think there is nothing wrong with spanking your children. My parents were very loving and giving, but they demamded respect, and when it was called for I got a spanking. My sister has tried lots of things to desipline her children, but nothing worked, so finally she started spanking them, you can see a big difference in there attitude and how much respect they have for her. I probably will spank my son when it is called for. There is a big difference between beating your children and teaching them right or wrong by spanking their bottoms.

Answer 9

look at the kids of today i think 90% of them need a good spanking

Answer 10

Wow. were you ever spanked? Just wondering. yes I do believe in it and I do think that it should be mandatory, there is a line between discipline and abuse and yes sometimes people cross it but I still think spare the rod and spoil the child. My children get spanked. And will continue to get it until they learn to stop doing wrong.