am i a bad vegan?

Question

i would like to take in some free guinea pigs, if i do, is it wrong because they are in a cage?

Answer 1

This is my opinion, and I'm not a vegan but I'm not anti-animal either.

It is only cruel to keep an animal in a cage, if the cage is too small, or if you NEVER take them out, or NEVER clean it. Guinea pigs are in cages for their own safety. If you let it run around, it would get lost and die in your house, or fall from something it climbed on, or whatever. It would be more cruel to let an animal get hurt out of its own natural curiosity than to protect it. You wouldn't let your toddler run around your house without a baby gate on the stairs, would you?

Technically all pets are in a "cage", except outdoor cats and dogs, and if they are fenced in, then that is a cage too. If it is an indoor pet, or on a leash of some sort...it is confinement. And emotionally, all pets are at least partially bonded to us because we feed them. If you didn't, your pet wouldn't "love" you, and I say that with full belief that animals are capable of showing love and affection...but they come to us first out of curiosity, and then they come back to us and start to love us because we give them something pleasant in return. They are kind of obligated to be compliant and obedient to the person who feeds them...and that is a form of attachment that can keep an animal from doing its own thing...a form of confinement as well.

This isn't a vegan issue, although you may have your own opinions about animal rights and how to pick and treat a pet. More important to you, I would think, would be how animals that you buy, are treated...and if you contribute to something abusive about meeting that demand, like puppy farms. If you plan to treat these animals well, and they aren't in the best situation now...then I'm sure they will enjoy their little guinea lives with you.

Just don't eat them. Then you would be a bad vegan.

Answer 2

Most of the people on here are right on track; vegans are caring individuals who love animals and want to protect them and help them have happy lives.

I would like to add however, I hope that these are rescue guinea pigs from a shelter or some such. Most self-respecting vegans and vegetarians would never buy (or take) an animal from a breeder or a pet store.

There are so many homeless, abandoned, abused and needing animals out there, it would be a shame to have someone breed others because it is specifically the type of animal you want. Also, pet stores are pure evil, and I can't imagine a vegan contributing to the animal suffering and cruelty that occurs for animals to end up there.

In the end the choice is up to you. Rescuing animals is a great thing for vegans to do. Also, be sure to research animal foods and products so you do not buy the ones that torture animals to feed your pet.

:)

Answer 3

You're not raising them for meat are U?
If you're not and if the cage is roomy and not like a prison cell then you're not a bad vegan.
A Vegan isn't just about not eating meat.. a Vegan is against all forms of cruelty to animals including putting them in small cages isn't a thing a good vegan would do. A Cage isn't wrong if there's lots and lots of space and it's
like the animals enivornment. I know one Vegan that had one bedroom allocated for her 2 hedgehogs! She didn't believe in caging animals! She got them from a pet store. She free them from the cage. Jody layed down in that bedroom they tickled her. The hedgehogs did their messes in a corner in where some kitty litter was placed!

Answer 4

Theoretically, a vegan should not have domestic pets (see Vegan Society website for statement from the mid-40s when the term veganism first started).
However, we all know that this world is unfortunately overrun with abandoned and unwanted pets. As a compassionate animal lover, it is almost impossible not to want to help out by taking such animals in.
I would personally say that if you are, in your opinion, rescuing them from a bad situation, and you are prepared to put in the effort needed to give them a really loving home then take them. Just remember they rely on you for everything, and once you've got them, you've got them til the day they die.

Answer 5

A person chooses to be a vegan for many reasons, but even for animal rights ones, you are taking care of them, have their best interests at heart (clean environment, fresh food and water and you love them). how can this make you a bad vegan? When they are out of the cage (this is their fortress) keep an eye on them as they are easy prey for cats and dogs and larger birds.

Answer 6

you need to call your self a bad vegan, a pescatarian who prefers vegan, or a flexitarian. properly, easily, I hate the be conscious flexitarian, whether that's available in case you opt to apply it, and it could greater healthful your case. Alternately, you need to basically attempt slightly greater good. :-) The lunch difficulty ought to have been complicated; next time, you need to ensure to have some nuts or an nutritional bar on your handbag, or do greater careful study on the eating places interior the section. I probable could have asked for a user-friendly (vegan) salad whether i became hungry, and made a factor of having something else from a different company later on. As for the "widespread" chocolate (come now, vegan chocolate is widespread, too - no longer something inherent in chocolate demands milk) and the milky coffee, properly, those are circumstances once you need to have basically steeled your self. If being vegan skill having chocolates much less in many situations, that's a stable factor, and you need to basically have tea in case you do in comparison to black coffee. (i do in comparison to black coffee, the two.) for sure, my vote is so you might basically attempt greater good, yet i will say that, for my section, somebody who's in many situations vegan yet eats something else (even meat, e.g. fish) as quickly as in a blue moon is doing greater desirable than a lacto-ovo vegetarian who eats dairy and eggs daily. that may no longer be a properly-liked stance (and that i will see the thumbs down coming), yet eggs, dairy, and meat truly are each of a similar from a ethical attitude, and by skill of eating as little of those products as accessible, you're doing properly.

Answer 7

Nah, unless you're into the whole PETA thing, they believe you shouldn't have animals as pets.
I have six guineas of my own and I make my own cages for them, just make sure you have enough space.
Some great guinea sites:
www.cavymadness.com
www.cavycages.com
www.cavyspirit.com
If you need anymore help feel free to send me a message! :D

Answer 8

There is nothing wrong with taking in homeless domesticated (captive-born or raised) animals. If you give your companion animals the proper environment and diet, they will live much longer, healthier lives than if they were released into a "wild" which they are not prepared for and cannot survive in.

Answer 9

SUE LET 'EM LOOSE BUT BE SURE TO WALL PAPER THE FLOOR AND WALLS AND COUNTERS WITH NEWSPAPER. COME TO THINK OF IT ITS EASIER TO KEEP THEM IN CAGES, THE IDEA IS TO HAVE A CAGE THAT IS LARGE ENOUGH SO THE PIGS CAN HAVE THEIR OWN PRIVATE SPACE. IF THE CAGE HAS SOME SIZE THEN IT ISNT WRONG TO KEEP THE PIGS IN A CAGE.

Answer 10

Yes. The culture we've created where it's okay to have an industry based around breeding animals for our amusement is even worse than eating them.

Think about it, people need to eat. They don't need to go "aww it's cute." Just because you're not going to eat them or use them doesn't mean that it's right to give them an artificial existence.

That said, if you just let them loose, they rapidly become food for predators. So it's up to you. Do you want them to contribute to nature, or live (however comfortably) in boxes to appease you?