Would you be open to criticism from members of your own religion?

Answer 1

Yeah. Constructive criticism is all right.

Answer 2

Yes. I would be open to criticism from members of any religion (so long they know what they are talking about).

Answer 3

I am open to criticism from members of my religion, or any other religion. What a person says to you is more important than the temple or church they attend.

Answer 4

Galations 6; 1 " Brothers, even thousgh a man takes some false step before he is aware of it, you who have spiritual qualifications try to readjust such a man in a spirit of mildness, as you each keep an eye on yourself for fear you also may be tempted."

My answer , then is yes, if i have made a serious mistake, then i should most definitely accept counsel, not necessarily criitism , from a qualified and mature person. This has nothing to do with peopel being judgemental, just helping one another, cause we all make serious mistakes.

Answer 5

properly it is person-friendly to appreciate as we've progressed technologically for the final 70 years God has had an probability to pop in and set the checklist at as quickly as . HAS he finished this ? No !! So i discover it stressful with the mounting info that the bible is only an astounding sort of hooee. Written by potential of folk with administration subject concerns and for the vulnerable minded human beings of the circumstances . seems each thinking individual replaced into persecuted and killed or banished for thinking the international revolved around the solar and an astounding sort of others . LIKE God did no longer reason the floor to rumble or volcanoes to erupt . technology explains plenty and for human beings to nonetheless settle for the bible as info of a few style of historic nature is only incorrect . there is little info to assist the Prophets existence no longer to point what proportion distinctive religions . some that have you ever married to 3 females to get in to heaven please forgive me in case you are able to no longer enable such religions alongside with Scientology or any others . i think of faith does the international a dis service and the certainty could learn . NO Santa clause or different such carried over pagan rituals .we could make up our very own . we could rejoice the tip of nuclear weapons day . the tip to international starvation day THE cleanser air for all day . we would desire to repair the mess we are making before it fixes us . Nature has a manner of wiping out species and convalescing . i'd desire to think of we are able to dangle around for no less than 60 extra years or so only to be on the secure component if i stay to be one hundred . At 40 i should not be longing forward to asserting i advised you so whilst i'm 70 and the sea stages have risen 10 ft ..it heavily isn't the tip of the international regardless of the undeniable fact that it's going to be a important inconvenience

Answer 6

I am Muslim, and I think that we should always listen to corrective criticism because it helps us to become better people.

However, this is the problem I have with criticism from Muslims. Muslim people tend to focus too heavily on Muslim Women's dress and whether or not she covers.

I don't cover my hair (unless I'm at the mosque), and I find that Muslim Women like yourself--women who do cover and especially Arabs--refuse to speak to me, refuse to give me greetings, or even acknowledge me after I have said "As-Salaam-Alaikum" in perfect Arabic.. That has been hurtful, but I've learned to live with this.

What bothers me is that the same people who wont give me greetings--are not necessarily better Muslims than me. The only way they judge women is by their dress. I'll give you a perfect example:
When I was going to college, there were a group of very pretty Muslim girls who were all close friends. They covered with hijabs and I didnt. They knew I was Muslim and we see each other at the mosque and on campus, but they would never give me the greetings or speak to me. This went on for a few years.

Well, before I graduted, I saw one of the Muslim girls walking outside. She was wearing her pretty hijab...and I looked down and saw that she was about 5 months pregnant. She was not married.

This whole time--they would never speak to me or other Muslim women who did not cover. Yet, they were committing Fornication.

I'm not saying they were bad Muslimahs because we all make mistakes. I just wish that Muslim, men and women--didnt look at the hijab as the Ultimate Measuarment of a Muslim Womens piety.

Allah has said

"Verily, the best clothing, is that of Righteousness".

Salaam

Answer 7

I wouldn't like it very much ,but I would not lose sleep over it.
We all for short of the ideals set forth by our faiths. This is why we are always a work in progress. No one has a right to judge us and their judgment would automatically put them at odds with what most religions teach.

Answer 8

I'm not religious, I'm spiritual. I'm open to criticism from anyone who wants to criticize me. I would only hope that instead of doing it behind my back that they would do it to my face. Then I would have a chance to discuss it with them and quite possibly change their mind.

Answer 9

Of course - as from anyone else. But then I'm going to check to see if the criticism is justified or not before I act on it.

Answer 10

Yes, but that criticism should be for (good purposes ~ like reforms in society and culture, welfare of human being, right / better practices of day to day work and not for 'Fitna and Fasad' (bad intentions).
And usually the pious people lead, guide and help for better activities.