what makes a christian attending church weekly a practicing christian but a Jew doing the same in temple not?

Question

so ino other words, Christians attend worship services, believe in Jesus, and of course they'd be considered a practicing Christian. A convert to Judaism who vows to follow the laws of the Torah but has only been a Jew for a short time would be considered a practicing jew. But a Jew who has been a Jew their entire life, celebrating every single holiday with their family, attending shabbat services on a regular basis, teaching Hebrew school, religious school and sunday school for 30 years but not keeping Kosher or being Torah observant would negate one's honor to say they are a practicing jew? any opinions on this?

Answer 1

All sounds a load of rubbish really, doesn't it?

Answer 2

because attending religious services is not what makes a Jew observant.

nowhere in the Torah dose it say you shall attend services on the Sabbath.

It dose say you shall keep the Sabbath holly and not desecrate it though acts of creation.


while I would agree that the above things you mentioned are important they do not negate a Jews need to do mitzvos.

how logical is it that a person claims that he is observant Jew because he attends services on the sabbath, but drives do Synagogue which is a direct biblical probation.

it would be the same as saying that he is a good father because he provides for his family, but how he provides is by stealing money from his company. Is he still considered a good provider?

Answer 3

I guess that's just the Jewish laws. However, going to church every week does not make one a practicing Chrisitan. That is just where our culture has taken Christianity. One is a Christian by repenting for sin and believing in Jesus. This would also make a Jewish person a Christian. But they have their laws they continue to keep and so be it until they have their eyes opened to the Messiah. There are many born again Jews who know the truth.

Answer 4

I'm not an expert on Christianity but say one would come to church weekly but not keep anything else in Christianity, or couldn't care less about many things. Just because this individual comes to church would not make him or her observant (which is short for fully observant, or at least tries).

Keeping kosher is part of Judaism. Excluding things like kosher means that one is not keeping all of Judaism and is then non-practicing. Sects such as reform, concervative or re-constructionists are inherently false. Religion can not be modified with the times or bent with one's will. This would undermine the point of observance - because it is God's will, not yours. Naturally this false "modification" has led to secularization because of new generations seeing the religion they are taught to be man designed, thus subject to one's will and whims.

Answer 5

I accept as true with you. in actuality, i might flow extra: why do such quite some Christians insist that our faiths are comparable while ideologically, they're poles aside? Christianity began as a dissident Jewish sect. yet as this faith unfold for the time of the Roman empire, and actually as quickly as Jesus became deified, then at that factor, the religions split aside forever. For us as Jews, G-d is G-d and guy is guy - they on no account 'merge'. The mere thought that G-d might take human style is BLASPHEMY. Jews have self belief that each and each physique people are the youngsters of G-d. Christianity has greater a very diverse perception gadget. It has taken the Jewish scriptures, MIStranslated them, REinterpreted them and additionally the assumption-approximately messiah, and now insists that we as Jews 'neglected' or have been too 'obdurate' to know our very own messiah! communicate approximately arrogance! Why don't greater Christians settle for that the very thought of 'messiah' is a JEWISH one. The JEWISH messianic prophecies have been written by JEWS, for JEWS. We as Jews use wisely translated Hebrew. in short, we understand OUR scriptures. yet no. Many Christians shield that Judaism is 'beside the point'. perfect. The Jewish and Christian G-d isn't the comparable G-d. How can or no longer it quite is, while Christians have self belief in the trinity? while they have self belief that G-d became made flesh in Jesus? And to those people who shop cheerfully pointing out that Jews regard Jesus as a prophet - no, we don't. We on no account did. We on no account will. CATALIZ - yet you have in simple terms long previous and neglected the considered necessary factor! In Judaism there isn't any such thought by way of fact the 'suffering' messiah! it quite is a CHRISTIAN concept. CATALIZ returned***********************************... You completely disregarded what I pronounced. The Jewish concept-approximately messiah does no longer contain ANY 'suffering' messiah. you're using a MIStranslation of the Torah. Kindly do no longer tell ME as a Jew what my faith would not 'understand' approximately OUR very own SCRIPTURES.

Answer 6

its obeying the Law that makes a person a good jew, not spending the holidays with his family. not obeying the Law does not make them any LESS of a jew - it just means that they aren't doing what G-d wants them, as jews, to do. whenever they want, they have a choice to become observant and immediately become a good jew again. its not like they are forever shamed because for a while they did not do the mitzvot. in judaism, all it takes is sincere atonement (ie, actively trying to improve your ways) and it is considered like you never disobeyed the Law in the first place. trying to be a better person is what matters to jews.

Answer 7

Well, hell-why don't you simplify it a little.
I think you are asking : if a Christian practices his religion and is called a practicing Christian, then why can't Jew who practices part of the Jewish tradition be called a practicing Jew.

Maybe you need to rephrase with about 1/3 the verbage.

Answer 8

You can go to church on a regular basis, belive, but if you don't put any of it into practice, your'e not really a christian. Seems to me to be the same for a jew. God told Saul He would have obedience rather than sacrifice.