psychiatrist vs psychologist?

Question

Ok, i see my psychchiatrist every couple of months. I havent been there in a while and I dont want to go back to him. I think he is more concerned with my money and I only spend about a good 3 minutes in his office EVERY TIME. He asks me how I am, all while writing a new refill script for me.

Is this normal? Is he supposed to councel?

So today I made an appointment with a psychologist. I figured that even tho he cant write out scripts (which I dont take regularly anyway) he will do a little bit of counseling right? I dont know what to expect...

Can you help me understand this?

randy-- you are a doctor?? surprising to me! you dont have a good bedside manner, nor do you have respect for others. I choose NOT to medicate myself, rather I use medatation. TYVM for your opinion.. but you are wayyyy off base. Maybe you shouldn't spend all day on YA and read up on some books.

Answer 1

Many people prefer to go to a Psychologist for counselling. The training of a Psychologist involves obtaining a Masters Degree or Doctors Degree in Psychology specializing in counselling and very little knowledge about Psychotropic medications or any other medications for that matter. They can't prescribe medications. A Psychiatrist is a Medical Doctor who has taken an Internship (1 year) followed by a Residency in Psychiatry (1 or 2 years) and then may specialize in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Adult Psychiatry or Forensic Psychiatry. They have a full Medical Training and are very familiar with Psychiatric medications and can order them and adjust them as necessary. Psychiatrists often care for the sicker patients such as those with Schizophrenia, Manic Depressive Illness, etc. who have major problems with Psychotic Behavior and Reality Testing. People with such problems as anxiety, mild to moderate depression, etc, often do well with 'talk therapy" or counselling and find a Psychologist with whom they feel comfortable in sharing feelings and talking about concerns and conflict resolution. Follow your heart and find a Psychologist with whom you can bond. The Psychologist can act as a liaison for you with a Psychiatrist if you both decide that a trial of medication would be helpful for you in addition to the counselling. Perhaps your psychiatrist thought you were getting counselling somewhere else. I am a Psychiatric Nurse Educator who taught Psychiatric Nursing in an RN Program for years. I specialized in Adolescent and Child Psychiatry and worked in that area in many different settings as well as had lots of clinical experience in Adult Settings too. You seem to be on the right track! Good Luck to you. Oh yes, I know Psychiatric medications inside and out all due to my clinical experiences and great desire for learning but I definitely have a warm spot for couselling.

Answer 2

You're right, a psychiatrist is a doctor and has very good knowledge of the chemicals that cause certain disorders in the brain. While psychotherapists work mostly on emotional reactions and help you learn how to cope with a mental illness that you have (and a psychiatrist can do this, too), a psychiatrist has the capacity to write you a prescription and help you with medication doses, etc. Psychiatrists are very valuable for this reason--a lot of mental illnesses can't be treated with counseling alone--the same goes for medication. A psychiatrist provides the best of both worlds, but for this reason they are more expensive and usually only deal with cases that really need their medical expertise.

Answer 3

A psychiatrist is a medical doctor with an M.D. degree, who can treat mental disorders and write prescriptions. He/she had to study for at least eight, and maybe even 12 years to get a degree as a specialist in this field.

A psychologist is more like an analyst. He or she does not have a degree in medicine. A psychologist can perform psychoanalysis, using hypnosis among other methods, and is principally a therapist.

Either professional can counsel patients, but their primary goal is to find out the source of the mental disorder. Psychologists often refer their patients to psychiatrists for medical treatment or further intervention. If you don't feel your psychiatrist is helping you, I would suggest changing doctors. You can still see the psychologist, and maybe he or she can recommend someone.

Answer 4

Well I feel lucky I go to a psychiatrist every other month and spend an hour with him....he ask how I feel what is going on in my life how my meds are working......I am usually there more than an hour he is always running behind.....Psychologist like a therapist can not give meds but can work with a psychiatrist who can give an ok on a scrip if you have been seen by Dr. first..............that is how it is where I go ...Now I have been to a Dr. Office where I felt like cattle being rushed through

Answer 5

I had the same experience. The difference, as you point out, is that a psychiatrist is a medical doctor that can prescribe medication. A psychologist is basically a bullshit artist. But if he's a good one, by all means take advantage of it.

Answer 6

yes the psychologist's job is to councel and advise you on your condition how things are going school, work, your home life etc. the 3 min time you spend with your dr is normal all they want to know is how you are doing that very moment and write scripts

Answer 7

Knowledge the makeup of any social condition and to be able to fold and manipulate the specific situation on your own end use is something which you dream on the you may be in total control of any condition applying Black Ops Hypnosis that you will find here https://tr.im/jY2c7 .
With this particular plan you will experience relaxation, peace and serenity. Relating with a established cases, with help from a clinical hypnotherapist, it is straightforward to stimulate this sensation in an individual anytime and the very best plan to discover that is Black Ops Hypnosis.
 

Answer 8

I am a retired mental health practitioner in a psychiatric outpatient setting, with 20+ years experience, and I can tell you that your description of your visit with your psychiatrist is EXACTLY what happens most of the time. Usually the doctors have little to no time whatsoever to spend talking with you due to the fees they charge and the number of people who want to see them in a very short period of time, so your assessment of his priorities is true, and then not always true. The psychiatrist is NOT supposed to counsel. You and the clinic could not afford it, unless you are very wealthy and are going to a private psychiatrist in a private setting, and then you would know how expensive counseling with them is, and they're mostly trained in medicine, not counseling. If you don't take your medicine as prescribed, you shouldn't be wasting yours and his time, and whoever's money you're spending to go see him. If you want to see a counselor, whether you call them Clinical Social Workers or psychologists or psychotherapists or marriage counselors or whatever, then do so, and THEY will counsel with you. But if you go to a psychiatrist, well, you'd better be very wealthy to spend any time at all to talk with them, for what reason I don't know since most are not trained as counselors. God Bless you.

Answer 9

A psychologist deals only with psychology. A psychiatrist is a Medical Doctor, that's why he can write scrips.

Answer 10

One of the most common questions spouses ask when confronting a marriage crisis is this: How can I save my marriage if my partner doesn't want to help find a solution? How do I succeed I am trying to save my marriage on my own? Learn here https://tr.im/njByF

It is a typical enough story: one partner leaves, the other stays. One remains 'in love', the other is uncertain. Whatever it is that has caused a couple to be apart, the one person who remains bears the prospect, fear, doubt, desire, hope of saving his or her marriage' alone.