Is this true: One of the acceptable reasons for U.S military discharge is being an only son/child?

Question

I read this somewhere but i need confirmation, please tell of other "out of the ordinary" reasons you know for military discharge.

Answer 1

This is WRONG ! See my note below this quote.

" The Sole Surviving Son policy in the military refers to a family that has two sons and one is already on Active Duty in a Combat zone..the policy states that the second can not serve."

My sisters' THREE boys are ALL in AFGHANISTAN right now, for the next 14 months ! All 3 in heavy combat situations'; and the ONLY concession the military makes now; is to keep them at least 100 miles apart. Other then that....nothing, no way, no how.

Answer 2

Yes There is a policy in effect that if you are an only son, OR say you and your brother are in the military, and your brother gets killed, they WILL discharge you and send you home. Its all about the families being able to pass on the family name and/or the blood lines. I do know they will allow you to enlist if you are an only son because I was in basic with at least 6 or 7 only sons and at least 2 or 3 males who were the only child. I do not know how or if they even would discharge you with no extenuating circumstances involved, though. You would probably need to do some more research.

As for other options for a discharge, you can always claim lunacy or pregnancy....although pregnancy would be pretty hard to convince them of!

Answer 3

This is absolutely false. How do I know? I was an only son and served during the Viet Nam era. The only out of the ordinary reasons would be medical reasons. Besides, there is no draft, won't be and if you are already in the US Military you obviously joined so why are you asking?And the Sole Surviving son policy...that just keeps you out of combat; not the military.

Answer 4

Partly correct...

The Sole Surviving Son policy in the military refers to a family that has two sons and one is already on Active Duty in a Combat zone..the policy states that the second can not serve.

This stems from WWII when the Five Sullivan brothers were lost at once on a ship that was torpedoed by Japs!

Answer 5

No it is NOT true. There is a policy whereby if a sibling or parent is killed IN COMBAT the sole surviving sibling may request a transfer out of direct combat role, but not out of the military.

This is an all voluntary military. you waive any consideration when you enlist.

Answer 6

No, it is NOT true. As stated previously, the policy of "sole surviving son" will only keep you out of combat IF YOU request it (the Army won't do it for you) it will NOT get you a discharge.

Answer 7

For one rape isn't as massive of an situation as information comments make it out to be. a woman has an analogous odds of being raped throughout the time of faculty as she does contained in the armed forces. Secondly, rape can, has, and does, ensue male on male. Rape is about having means and administration over someone and is not any longer inclusive to at least one gender. examine Lord of the Flies to study what adult men are able to even as remoted at the same time for lengthy classes of time. an extra desirable be conscious, even as adult men are treated like animals as they're specially departments of the armed forces, they have a tendency to act like animals.

Answer 8

You posted this twice? How desperate are you to get out of the military?

Answer 9

I've heard that, but the person who told me that was also the last living male of the paternal family line. (His dad, grandpa, and on up had previously died and only had sisters.)

Answer 10

don't ask, don't tell