Wouldn't it make sense?

Question

Since there are so many claiming that Americas economy would collapse without all the criminal trespassers we currently have, Wouldn't it be more logical for ALL the immigrants to leave and allow Americas economy to collapse? Why do they continue to enable Americas greatness? As long as they are here, according to their logic, The American economy will remain strong. If they left, According to them, America would be no more in a very short time. This is a conflict of interest to my way of thinking. What do YOU think about this theory?

I notice that kehkohjones and the bitchdoctor totally avoided the question and instead went directly to the verbal personal abuse. Answer the question, dont sidestep it, or do you not have an answer besides personal attacks and misguided propaganda?

Answer 1

Good point. ILLEGALS did you read THAT?

Answer 2

Ok, let's try it this way, we give all illegals an ID card, numbered by when they came in for deportation. As long as they volunteer to go home for no less than 1 year, we'll give them a free pass to come back in......... here's the catch, during a term of no less than 1 year, the US economy must suffer a collapse. If we cannot live without illegal workers, then we can bring them back and they can take their jobs and they can be law abiding citizens. We'll call their number in the order they left (first out, first back in) until we are 'full'. During the no less than one year period though, we will continue to work through the 8 Million legal applicants waiting for entry. If they can't fill up the spots needed, we'll bring in the assumed 12 Million excess. If we need more, we'll swallow our pride and admit it. If we don't need them, then they stay the hell out and stop with the tired lies of being the 'backbone of the US economy'. Good idea, or am I talking out the other side of my face again?

kjones:
1. Hispanics have Euro blood if you really define it.
2. As a Native, even I am willing to admit that we didn't all populate this continent first, we came from across the straights.
3. Even if you argue for Hispanic land rights, it's all south of the US border. Aztlan artifacts were found on the border, but Mexico's side of it.
4. Granted the Natives didn't have alot of say in the first colonies, but treaties lined out the expansion. The colonists redrew, then broke the treaties, but were acting legally for a small period of time.
5. In order to colonize the New World, Spain and Portugal had to get a Papal sanction and draw out the borders beforehand. Why would they do this if there were no rules? Why would they do this if it wasn't to proclaim which land was whose and who would be trespassing?
6. As I said, I'm a Native. We lost the war for our land. I'm not going to forget it, but I'm going to get over it.

Answer 3

Quite frankly, I think you're an idiot. Since they are coming here for the hope of a better life why in the world would they want that economic system to collapse? Are you really this shortsighted and simplistic? Do everyone a favor, turn off the O'Reilly Factor and read a book. *sigh*

Answer 4

What makes sense out of anything these days. There is truly way to much hatred and racism. No matter how much anyone complains, nothing is going to change. I am a US citizen and I am white. Even if we voted the ones in leadership out and got new ones, I don't believe that would change a thing. There will and always has been hatred and racism.

Answer 5

kehkohjones demonstrates a wisdom you so lack...i can hardly believe you think you have something to contribute to those who can think for themselves...which one of your many personalities have we here...renegade, panocha4ever, or First L...your logic is flawed...do you consider this a real answer to the flawed medicine of Congress...simplistic medicine just to post your pearls is illogical and not well thought out; read the answer by kehkohjones...and provide a way for the man to have a fair shot at you...hehehe...i will never be in agreement with your blind philosophies about a man who has his feelings hurt over being confused for a Mexican...and all your nonsense postings...you speak out of both sides of your mouth when you appear as more than one ID...

Answer 6

Hey I never though of that!!! If they realy wanna show us, why dont they plan another May Day where they all get and leave he country all at once. That will really teach us a lesson.

illegal immigrants are so full of s h i t. They know d amn well if they get up and leave, they wont make as much money as they did in their home country!

Answer 7

Your conflict is that you think. You refer to "criminal ttrespassers" but you forget that unless you are Native American, YOU are a criminal trespasser, too. Besides, MAN made the borders. Hispanics were the first here... so, are you referring to those "criminal respassers" that speak Spanish and are a little darker than Caucasians or ALL of the White Europeans, and Canadians, too?

If you blame those that come from the northern borders as not paying taxes, what about the large super-rich and powerful corporations that get huge tax incentives and don't pay their fair share of taxes but turn around and send American jobs to countries where women get paid less than men, and where they pay a couple of dollars to have children who are abused and made to work 10 and 12 hours a day?

Do you also blame those that come from the northern border from not paying taxes for doing landscape work for some contractor who is the one making money off the work he pays a pittance for, and then HE doesn't pay taxes or insurances or jack s h i t?

Would you clarify and let us know if by "criminal trespassers" you mean ALL those from Canada and New Zealand, too? Or just those of a little darker complexion? State your agenda clearly... are you trying to keep America White? If so, do some reading, America has became the world power it is today on the backs of non-Whites... in case you are doing some selective reading of history that excludes Hispanics, Chinese, Japanese, Native Americans, BROWN and BLACK people that were either immigrants, legal or otherwise, born here or brought here in chains or immigrated here to do as your forefathers did... make a decent living in a democratic republic (now converted to a Plutocratic Republic by the puppet in elected offices).

Renegade, you sent me an email without giving a functional return email to reply. Here's my reply to your ambush!
Yes, and unfortunately I am only 1/3 Taino and through no fault of my own MY true 100%-blooded ancestors were entirely decimated by the beginnings of the 1700s by the Europeans that arrived on the shores of Boriken (which means, Land of the Noble Chieftain), and we were "discovered" in spite of the fact that our people inhabited our land well over 2,000 years BC, according to Carbon dating findings during the early 1990s. What we have now are "mestizos" but our blood runs as red as yours.

Your "education" efforts requires more substance than heresay; I think for myself and arrive at my own conclusions without having to repeat the hateful, bigoted propaganda that separates rather than unites people... YOU do all people harm by being a pawn for the demagogues.

I did not choose my parents nor where I was born no more than you did. "Immigrant" is too loosely thrown around nowadays since the original people of these lands did not establish borders but the Europeans and White Man did; why do you emulate them who separate us with hateful propaganda in order to conquer us? Now, are you going to blame me for that, too? Have you not learned from history? Vitriole? I reciprocate your judgement since you need to review history; YOU would impose another Trail of Tears on others? I refer you to read (or re-read) Dee Brown's "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee."

I still wear my shoulder-length hair, do you? I would defend YOUR rights even if you do not defend the rights of others.

Answer 8

We was a strong country before them and we will be a strong country after their butts are deported.........

yes on HR 4437 stop the criminals and the illegals they protect..

Answer 9

Why would we want to get rid of the 'good' immigrants?

I just don't think we want the illegals, and those who enable illegals.

Answer 10

Logical. I just don't understand why immigrants come here to have the "American Dream" and don't adopt our language or try to assimilate to our culture. oooooooooooooooooo don't get me going.

Answer 11

By that logic then, they don't want our country to collapse, maybe.