Do you think that Muslims should responsible for their brothers and sisters fanatical actions.?

Question

If one Muslim is living next to another Muslim, and he or she suspects them of some sort of terrorist activity, or even spreading ill feelings about his host counry and its original inhabitants, should they take responsibility and do the right thing by turning them in to the Police or allerting one of the authorities concerned.
Should the average law abiding Muslim do more to repel the fanatical fundementalists who are ruining the previously good name of most Muslims and Islam.????Or is the situation we are in at the moment actually more political than relegious based.

Its not about relegion my question. Its about doing the right thing in society, the decent thing.
If you had a couple of small kids, and you suspected a paedophile had moved in next door, and was entertaining little childre etc, wouldnt you dob him in ?????????

Answer 1

When it comes to terrorism, YES!!!!! It's true that every man/woman is responsible for his/her own actions, butif you're an Imam at a mosque or any other Muslim that knows that another Muslim is planning and plotting terror activities, that Muslim should turn the other Muslim in. Race and ethnicity have nothing to do with it. I mean seriously, if you're a white man in the trailer park doing toe best you can to raise your family and the guy next door is over there cooking up crystal meth, that guy should do the right thing and report 'meth' man before his trailer blows up and hurts innocent people. Too many Muslims want to shield their brethren from the law, even though many of these Muslims are engaging in terrorist activities.

Answer 2

Do I think that Muslims ( here you should be given the benefit of the doubt , therefore everyone reading this shall pre - suppose that you really do , in the bottom of your heart , which knows no bounds , do mean people , don't you , I mean , people , the 2 legged kind the can be found walking around practically any where on this planet , I shall pre - suppose that if you were living any where within 6000 miles of Pyong Yang you would be calling them oriental , you sound like rather a discerning chap it's a shame about the discriminating bit ) should ( be , is the word you're looking for isn't it ) responsible for their brothers and sisters actions ?
Who said " the crimes of the fathers should NOT be visited upon the sons " .
Now I am not a gambling person , ( far too many poor peoples money going into that lark ) BUT , and here because of thunderbolts and lightening I am hazarding my life in an attempt to answer your question , by GUESSING that the the above quotation would / does go up to and is INCLUSIVE OF brothers and sisters , and , THIS ALSO has sweet fanny adams to with if they survive on fish and chips , krill or chum and I am one very fine fair hair away from calling you a dikfir , but , I wont because of thunderbolts lightening and you need to call somebody your brother ! ! !
Now , the answer I have given YOU pertains only to your very first question , the one concerning brothers and sisters , got it ?
How old are you , got any kids , right let us all imagine you have seven ( little brides for seven little brothers , humour mate ) , and the one in the middle hnocks her porridge of the dining room table after Jeeves very dilligentlly brought all seven of them their seven plates of porridge , WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO , beat the stuffing out of all seven of them just in case the porridge on your little bit of a silk rug ( too many kids for a carpet , right ) was knocked off the table by one whose porridge it was not , and none of them would own up to it because they were " scared " to , scared of you in your blessed little rotten cotten socks , watch yer bottle mate thats all i can say , I mean there are seven of them , as for yer bottle you could probably get the hem taken in a bit !

Answer 3

If someone I knew was committing a crime that was likely to harm other people (so I'm not talking about not paying your road tax or working a bit on the side) I'd feel obliged to turn them in.
The same goes to for the Muslims that hide their neighbours from investigation - they're aiding and abetting, so are to an extent guilty themselves. The problem with the Islamic community is that they haven't integrated into our society and so have closed ranks and feel the need to protect one another more than they feel the need to protect society as a whole. I think that this makes them more dangerous, especially when you throw religion into the equation and they genuinely believe that they are doing the "right" thing.
In answer to your question, I think that the motives for Islamic terrorism are both political and religious, but the religious element makes it all the more terrifying as they can convince themselves (and their neighbours) that they are acting with total impunity and so need to be sheltered from police scrutiny.

Answer 4

Yes, I think they should alert the authorities if they suspect something fishy is going on ...just as you would alert the authorities if you have reason to suspect someone is running a child pornography ring or planning a bank robbery .. don't think it has so much to do with being a Muslim as being an upright honest citizen ... of course Muslims who are concerned that their religion is dragged in the mud and everybody tarred with the same brush would of course have a special interest in being vigilant in that regard I would have thought .....

Answer 5

We all have a responsibility to hold accountable each other for our actions. Muslims are not an exception, Jews are not an exception, and Christians are not exception. The terrorists use their ancestral faith to justify their actions, but essentially God want his children to live in peace. Jews, Muslims, and Christians are the children of Abraham through his sons Isaac and Ishamel. They use to live in harmony until the Crusades.

Answer 6

A Man/Woman Should Be Responsible For His/Her Own Actions Not Others

Answer 7

If your brother, sister, mother or father went out and stabbed some one in a pub fight, are you to blame?

You cannot blame other Muslims for a small MINORITY!

I do believe this problem can only be resolved by the Muslim community its self.

Answer 8

I don't care what religious beliefs people have, I think everybody should be looking for anybody behaving in an unusual manner and report it to the police ASAP, we all bleed and we all hurt when we lose loved ones, all stick together and beat the terrorists!!!

Answer 9

Here's the truth!!! These guys are condemning the police for the arrests made as they MIGHT be innocent and upset their families.
WAKE UP feckers! What if they are GUILTY? These people only think of themselves and not the innocent who would be murdered by these pric*s.
'Cos they are born here doesn't mean they're British..... YOU'RE NOT!!!!

Answer 10

Extremist Muslims are not following Islam!