English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Arabic is a language of only small number of muslims. but during my travels to non arabic speaking muslim countries, i saw muslim s repating arabic koranic verses that even they dont understand. These people are made to byheart the entire koran in arabic like parrots without knowing even the meaning of one word.
How stupid do you thin they are?

2006-07-06 23:43:52 · 19 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

19 answers

You are the stupid one thinking that this is stupid ...

Can't you see what they are trying to do ... They are trying to protect Quran from getting corrupted just like Bible and Torah ...

They are trying to prevent Quran from getting translated and then re-translated and re-translated on and on ... till the real meanings are corrupted ...

And then many versions of the Quran appears ... just like the Bible and Torah...

And when they need to learn a meaning of a certain verse they refer to a translation of the MEANING of that verse in their own mother language ...

2006-07-09 22:48:25 · answer #1 · answered by mai4islam 3 · 0 0

Do you understand the Latin words spoken in Church?!

Qur’an wasn't intended to be just read only. It's a way of life and instructions that go so deep to your smallest needs, just as the other holly books. Arab Muslims can read Qur’an easily but as you know not all Muslims are Arabs. The problem here my friends is these non-Arab nations are so poor or they just didn't have the source of learning Arabic (it's a long story). They have all the well to learn but the privilege of extra time s not there because they either work and feed their children or they will be thrown on the streets. The least they could reach is learning reading in Arabic which is mostly a personal effort

I must say, it's sad that these people didn't the have the chance to learn on of the basics of Islam. I
It's sad to happen to any follower to any religion, being far from God just as much as want to be close.

Islam has been, still and will be a misunderstood religion. We can blame anyone if we want or just find Islam guilty.
I'd say Islam is not wrong; it was just implemented the wrong way.

People are always afraid of what they don't know, but some of them take the chance and try to touch the truth. I think we need to have more compassion and understanding to other people, cultures & religions. Don't you think it's better than making of fun people?

Forgive my language and style.., I’m writing you from the office..!(woops)

Good luck

2006-07-09 18:46:11 · answer #2 · answered by Fahad 2 · 0 0

Reading Quran and Memorising it is the actual reason that the quran is the same as it was 1400 years ago. why their are so many versions of bible? because there is no bible in its origional language. if a muslim learns the quran by heart and he doesnt attempts to know its meaning it definetly is his fault not the fault of islam.
your next question that seems is why quran is in arabic? Arabic can explain most complex things in few words. it has thousands words for one thing and yet everyword has its own independent meaning. shortly i would say Arabic is the Best language in The world. Remember i am not an Arab by myself, i am a pakistani and speak pushto and urdu and sometimes english, i also know arabic.

2006-07-06 23:56:21 · answer #3 · answered by Yasir Saeed 2 · 0 0

Quran is the word of almighty God. Have you ever heard a recitation of Quran? If so, you'll understand. It has a tremendous effect on its reciter in its original language. Thats why they do it. Hundreds years back, Arabic was the language of science and astronomy and Arabic will be the global language in the end times of this world and Arabic will be the language of here after. Better if you cannot appreciate that, mind your own business.

2006-07-07 00:35:03 · answer #4 · answered by M. M. Azmil 1 · 0 0

Most of them know the meaning, and of course, there are also translations of the Koran. The point in having it in Arabic is to ensure it won't be altered.
Christians used Latin too for 1000 years, and the poor people had no idea what they do at all in the church.

2006-07-06 23:46:55 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

You r right my friend but just think it this way...
Have u ever heard of some one who has learnt whole bible, or any other worldly book by heart???
I am sure u haven't....
But see, there are 9.2 billion registered" Hafiz-ul- Qur'aan".(Qur'aan learnt by heart people which are certified to be true & complete learner of Qur'aan).
Along with this there are also millions of muslims who learn Qur'aan but have no access to a certified Hafiz or institute of Qur'aan.sso they r not registered..
Also there are people who have learnt half or a part of it.

Now see what do we conclude from this?
Only the Qur'aan (in Arabic) has some spiritual thing due to which muslim children even of age 5 can also learn it easily.
U know the youngest person who is certified Hafiz is just 6years old.

As far as learning it by heart but not understanding the real meaning of it is now-a-days becoming common as people have lesser time to pray due to worldy deeds............

2006-07-06 23:58:45 · answer #6 · answered by just curious 1 · 0 0

Amen (LOL) johnny zondo.

At least most muslims learn arabic (the language the qu'uran was actually written in). Most christians read the bible in English, which means what they are reading has been transcribed and translated from other languages at least twice!

2006-07-06 23:49:06 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

They are not stupid.At least you shouldn't think so if you don't understand the Holy Book.They Learn Quran by heart because they believe in the blessings of Quran.A lot of people read Quran along with translations like me.And you don't know about them,how many they are.

2006-07-07 00:25:55 · answer #8 · answered by uncoolmom 5 · 0 0

you are absolutely wrong ..
muslims dont recite the quran like parrots.
though not everyone would understand every single word in quran.muslims know the meaning of most of the words and teachings of the holy quran.
by keepin the quran in its orignal form means that it remains the same and unchanged.arabic is the main language of islam.

2006-07-06 23:52:33 · answer #9 · answered by kichuna1 2 · 0 0

The stupid person is the one who don't understand Islam and don't respect others...Muslims know all meaning of Quran and you can see this that all muslim woman wear vail and all muslims pray..they seek to obey god by any way...

2006-07-06 23:57:43 · answer #10 · answered by sweetshima 2 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers