Why shouldn't we question or judge God?

Question

-He will know we do it anyway, before we do it,because He knows everything
-He is all-powerfull, so we can't hurt Him
-He made enough errors to get blamed for, if He's all-knowing He probably also knows all his error.

If he gave us Free Will, he also gave us the right to judge Him.

Answer 1

Because God is ALWAYS right.Never wrong.He knows what he's doing up there.Dont question anything he does.

Answer 2

You are free to question anything or anyone you want. What worries me is the notion of "judgment." When we judge something, we assign value or make a definite statement regarding something. "I think smoking cigarettes is unhealthy." -- This is a judgment. You can question my judgment -- you might ask me, why do you feel that way? Then to support my judgment I would need evidence, like medical studies or watching my grandparents die from lung cancer, and so forth.

When it comes to a divine entity, judgments are impossible. It is impossible for me to issue a definitive statement about the divine. Because that means I know something about the divine, and I have reasons or evidence for my knowledge. "God is all-powerful." -- What evidence or reasons can I give for such a statement? Have studies been conducted? Have I had a direct-experience of God's omnipotence? Or perhaps I believe God is all-powerful because that seems to be implied in the very meaning of the concept of God?

I would say question everything. But reserve your judgments for things which you know to be true.

For an excellent analysis of judgment and understanding, read the 4th Meditation of Renee Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy (link below).

Answer 3

Judge not, lest ye be Judged.

He gave us Free Will because it was fair, he may not like it. I always question Faith, Religion, and those in charge....... I guess that means I question God (but when I was 3 I questioned my Dad too, so I may be a trouble maker). Some feel that questioning God is blasphemous because he is right. He just is. No questions about it. Others see it as healthy because you are stronger in your faith because it has been tested and passed. I vote for the latter.

Answer 4

May I ask why you are so angry with God? Why do you feel the need to judge Him? Who gave any of us the right to judge the Almighty?

I would suggest you read the book of Job, specifically chapters 38-39. It begins with God saying, "Job, where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?".

We have no right to put ourselves in the place of God.

Answer 5

The whole point of God is mystery. Since no one has a direct line, one cannot really KNOW. Therefore we can only presume, which creates the need to question, especially when it is someone else's presumption that may not agree with our own.

Answer 6

Never says we absolutely should not question God. Job did. Moses did. Both also argued.

Judging, in the sense you imply, also implies the ability to carry out that judgment. You can't carry out your sentence against God.

Answer 7

Because many are afraid that their faith cannot stand against logical scrutany. That said, not only does God know we will question things, I believe he expects us to. What's better, blind faith, or, after careful questioning coming back to what you originally believed? Furthermore, I am a very curious person. I question everything, especially that which cannot be proven. Would God condemn me for being who I am, who he made me? I would sure hope not.

Answer 8

Where exactly does it say you have the "right" to judge Him?
You may have the ability but that is not the same as a right.
"As for me and my house we will serve the Lord"
Peace of Christ,
Debra

Answer 9

I remeber thinking one day if God is going to destroy me he will destroy me no matter what I do or what i believe. so i gave God a sex change a different name and a different personality and i stood up to the bible god who was a tyrant anyways.

Answer 10

I totally agree.You make a decision and when it goes wrong you blame it on God.tHOSE WHO DO THAT ARE ACTING LIKE IDIIOTS.its not his fault.Just because he gave you the choice doesnt mean he picked for you.

Answer 11

go a head a judge him. where is your prison? what power do you have to judge him? None that would even touch him. you will be judged in the same manner that you Judge others.