Do illegal immigrants provide cheap labor? Or is it a myth?

Question

It is cheap for the greedy employers, but not the American taxpayers?

To enlightment: there is a difference between illegal and legal immigrants.

Answer 1

They provide cheap labor for the employers, but the regular folk have to pay the difference every day.

Sassy, they can get EIC for much more than $3200. It's over $4,800 they can get. Plus they can get additional child tax credit.

Answer 2

That is definitely NOT a myth. Illegal immigrants aren't covered under social security or any health benefit and worker's comp plans, so employers don't have to pay for any insurance or anything for them. They don't have as many opportunitites (depending on where they originate) in their home countries to make money, so minimum wage is usually considered acceptible, if not a lot to them. Therefore, they provide relatively cheap labor under the table.

Answer 3

It is true. But who, other than the employers, benefits from them being cheap labor? Supply and demand sets prices, nothing else. Prices can only rise as much as people are willing to pay.... no higher, so those saying we will be paying 20 bucks for a head of lettuce are full of it.

Answer 4

No, they are costing us a fortune. If they come over here with a wife and 5 kids, at a cheap wage, he pays no income tax and if he does at the end of the year, he gets an earned income credit for up to $3200.00 free. He qualifies for subsidized housing and subsidized rent. He qualifies for free health care. His children get welfare benefits, free breakfasts and lunches at school. He requires bilingual teachers and books. He qualifies for relief of high energy bills. If he becomes aged, blind or disablee he qualifies for SSI. Once he qualifies for SSI he can qualify for medicare. All this we pay for.
He does not have to worry about car ins.,life ins, or home owners ins. Taxpayers provide Spanish langueage signs, bulletins and printed material. He cannot be fired, harrassed, or sued. He and his family receive the equivvalent of $20. to $30. and hour in benefits while working Americans are lucky to have 5 or 6 dollars an hour left after paying their bill and his. We also pay for increased crime, graffiti, and trash cleanup. Cheap labor? I don't think so.

Answer 5

It is a myth. It drives citizens into poverty and onto welfare rolls when a citizen's gross pay is greater than the net pay an illegal gets, and the employers don't pay the costs of local schools and health care. They should.

Answer 6

Everywhere, slimeball politicians need immigrant labor to keep the economy going, but use foreigners as scapegoats to secure thier own power--to affirm xenophobia and loyalty of native-born to state.


So in hating immigrants you are working in the interests of the State, who exploits your labor also and thinks you are worht as much if not less than an "immigrant" at least they stand up and resist, you bow and kiss the *** of Power and will be shat on as a consequence.

say ah.

Answer 7

i do no longer understand what galaxy you stay in, yet yikes... A. The Earned earnings Tax credit is that, earned. It basically is going to those that actaully artwork for a living. B. It basically is going to those that record earnings taxes, some thing unlawful immigrants are unlikely to do, because of the fact it may divulge them to federal scrutiny. the reason a farmworker could qualify for area 8 (this is being cut back), lease (being cut back), nutrition stamps (being cut back) and Medicaid (being cut back) is they stay properly under the poverty line. the reason he does not would desire to hardship approximately automobile coverage is he can no longer arise with the money for a automobile. life coverage? maximum farmworkers could relatively like life coverage - they're uncovered to unsafe chemical factors on a each and daily foundation. sources vendors coverage? maximum can slightly arise with the money for lease. If something happens to their living house, they lose each little thing. can not be fired, burdened or sued????? Farmworkers are between various the main abused workers in u . s . a .. they're in many cases threatened with deportation in the event that they do no longer provide into to employers demands. i do no longer understand the place you purchased the $20-$30 determine, possibly Anne Coulter or another raving lunatic, in spite of the undeniable fact that it does not replicate something close to to the certainty for many migrant workers living contained in the US.

Answer 8

Its true. No offense, but I can't really say that I'm willing to go out in a field and work for 8 hours picking lettuce with a salary of $5.15. Are you?

Answer 9

It is a myth. On a free market the prices are ruled by offer and demand and nothing is cheap or expensive, just we much of something or we are short of something.

Answer 10

It is true

Since they are breaking the law in some way, they don't have any right to exige a real salary, so people who employ them many times pay lower than they would pay a normal citizen.