Which lens should I purchase for my Grand Canyon hike?

Question

The Nikon 12-24 doesn't have a lot of great reviews. Cost too much and doesn't perform accordingly. Would an 18-55 get me decent photos? Or should I go a bit wider? I would like a lens that is versatile (weddings, portraits, indoors, etc). The Nikkor 18-55 only goes to an F-Stop of 3.5. Is that enough for indoors? The Tamron 18-200 doesn't have great reviews either. What about Sigma 10-20? Is that too wide? Would I get use out of it after the trip?

Answer 1

I think the Nikon 12-24 is a fine lens and may be just right for your GC hike, actually. The Tokina version is rated highly as well. You'll want something that goes pretty wide (this provides something like a 100 degree to 55 degree field of view on a camera with an APSc sensor, like the D200, D80, D70, etc.

I wouldn't touch the 18-55 - I don't think it's a very good lens. The 18-70 is better, and is very light and has a good zoom range. However, I think you'll enjoy having something wider.

Answer 2

If you're looking to shoot broad landscapes and unique close ups consider the 10.5mm. It gives 180 degree angle of view.

If you take a lens like that and work with some unique perspectives you can't go wrong.

Of course, at the other end of the spectrum a strong telephoto in the 400 to 600 range will give some unbelievable sunsets but then you're really talking some money. It is also possible to rent some special lenses for such expeditions.

Answer 3

I'd go for the Sigma 10-20... it will give you awesome wide shots of the canyon. After your trip, you may enjoy it too, for architecture shots, city shots, landscapes, and you can do some fun close ups of folks, animals and things... it's also great for interior shots.

Another alternative is, you can rent a lens or two.. and see which you prefer, and purchase that lens at a later date.

Answer 4

Didn't I answer this with reference to a review of the Sigma 18-200mm lens?