Christians do u agree with Muslim theory , that person crucified was a criminal & not real Jesus ?

Question

i hear many muslims say that, the person crucified on cross was not real jesus, infact he was a cheat & criminal ( who acted like jesus). Jesus didn't die at all.

they believe that jesus was taken to heaven by allah , do you agree with muslims ?

Answer 1

I believe in none of the theories that have no basis with science.

But I do believe that the MAN called Jesus was an enlightened soul that taught the world a way to live. I rate hin with the same revere as Buddha, or the prophet Muhammed or any of our Hindu sages. They all had a message that their followers never really understood.

They wanted to unite people, but only one flaw - they never realised that the truth us sacred. Just like you keep a sacred thing away from your common things, so should be truth. Maybe this world would have been a better place had these people kept their realisations to themselves instead of hoping agains hope that a common man will understand. Out of their love for rectifying man, they ended up dividing mankind

... but that's just a thought of a small time person like me. I have miles to go and those people have already been there. I accept that I may be totally wrong about the last paragraph.

Answer 2

I am a practising Christian, I strongly believe in Holy Bible. Therefore, being a Christian I do not find any justification and do not agree with the so called Muslim theory.

Second part of your question that real Jesus was not crucified in cross, instead was a cheat & criminal. I consider this statement about Jesus's crucification can be with a vested hidden interest by the concerned person/group to tarnish the image of Christians.

The crucification of Jesus Christ took place as believed around 2000 years back when the society, culture, education and relevant system for recording etc. were active. Therefore the actual incident that took place can be verified from written books/records by the eye witnesses and also from the available material evidences as on date

I humbly & totally disagree with your statement/question and go fully with the word of our Lord as contained in the HOLY BIBLE.

I simply ask you to go through your question once again "Christians do you agree with Musilim theory, that person crucified was a criminal & not real Jesus"?, then you may understand where I stand in answering this question. Because, your statement derived after hearing from many muslims, as stated by you, against an establised & traditional religion.

If one cannot believe a particular religion, but should not question the true followers without any proven reasons. Let us lead a harmonious religious life.

Answer 3

Islam is the oldest of religions preached by 1,24,000 prophets, from Adam to Muhammed.!Jesus the forerunner before Muhammed was also a prophet of Allah . Further, the Quran being the last revelation,replaces all earlier ones and remains the authentic word of God.
It emphatically declares that "Hesus was neither killed nor cucified !"(H.Q. 4 {156). And "allah has raised him up to Himself!"(H.Q.4 : 158).
The disciples of Jesus : Petr, John and Barna bas affirmed that Jesus was never crucified,
Basil dans, Docetate and Marcionite Christians alo do not beleive in the thoery of crucifixion of Jesus.
Crucifixion implies nailing the human body and breaking bones. OT does not accept this.
The latest revelations prove that deification and crucifixion of Jesus was done to attract the Romans to this newly created religion.
Vested interests created the doctrine of trinity and some fifty years ago,they have given it up!
Now that it is given up, it follows that Jesus is no more the Holy Son, then how coulld he save the believers in him?

Answer 4

Muhammad organized 65 military campaigns in the last ten years of his life and personally led 27 of them. The more power that he attained, the smaller the excuse needed to go to battle, until finally he began attacking tribes merely because they were not part of his growing empire.

After Muhammad’s death, his most faithful followers and even his own family turned on each other almost immediately. There were four Caliphs (leaders) in the first twenty-five years. Three of the four were murdered. The third Caliph was murdered by the son of the first. The fourth Caliph was murdered by the fifth, who left a 100-year dynasty that was ended in a gruesome, widespread bloodbath by descendents of Muhammad’s uncle.

Muhammad’s own daughter, Fatima, and his son-in-law, Ali, who both survived the pagan hardship during the Meccan years safe and sound, did not survive Islam after the death of Muhammad. Fatima died of stress from persecution within three months, and Ali was later assassinated. Their son (Muhammad’s grandson) was killed in battle with the faction that became today’s Sunnis. His people became Shias. The relatives and personal friends of Muhammad were mixed into both warring groups, which then fractured further into hostile sub-divisions as Islam grew.

Muhammad left his men with instructions to take the battle against the Christians, Persians and Jews. For the next four centuries, Muslim armies steamrolled over unsuspecting neighbors, plundering them of loot and slaves, and forcing the survivors to either convert or pay tribute at the point of a sword.
Source(s):
http://www.thereligionofpeace.com/

Answer 5

The Koran states that Jesus became into not crucified as a results of fact God replaced him with yet another guy or woman! if so, then why would God try this except God holds him the optimal place, that he did not decide on Jesus to go through. yet many inclusive of Muhammad go through an extremely painful loss of life. Why did not God spare him the painful loss of life, and in simple terms took him, to illustrate in his sleep. Does meaning Jesus is so lots extra substantial to God than Muhammad, he did not decide on him to experience any soreness! Why could we've self assurance in what the Koran claims on the subject of the Crucifixion, and not have self assurance Jesus Christ himself, who has stated many cases what's going to ensue. The time and the tactic, and all that surpassed off after that. Jesus became into praying and asking God, to offer him potential, to undergo the soreness this is coming, not to not kill him. and if that fact is real, then the thought that Jesus became into not crucified will become invalid. So this is it, if he wasn't crucified, then why pray that God decide on enable different kill him. all of it sums to a minimum of one substantial component, if what the Koran claims to be real! then, Jesus Christ is the single, and anybody inclusive of Muslims could carry him interior the optimal regards to the single that God secure the main, yet on condition that it became into real! Jesus became into Crucified, he got here for a objective, and that's what he has executed. evidence. Many have envisioned it, prophesied it. not purely a comprehend 1 guy or woman, many. because it incredibly is been written. are you able to offer a evidence he wasn't? The Qu'ran became into written by using hassle-free people. Or did somebody overlook that Muslims declare that Muhammad became into illiterate, or wasn't he!!! if so, then the only miracle of the Koran isn't.

Answer 6

My My Hector, that is it. Don't be disillusioned. It was almost premeditated if not. Jesus knew he was going to heaven the question being when, he may have made the situtation arise so that he did'nt have to wait till his natural health death. I believe he made the situation of his death to occur at 33. Allah is no where near Jesus or God. Allah is in another place where ancestors who die go there and have a life with houses, clothes, food etc. etc.

Answer 7

There is a new book available with www.amazon.com titled A Man that is Called Jesus by AR Malabari, which is a rare and aunique book on Jesus.This in fact is an Encyclopaedia covering the entire life of Jesus unlike other similar book.

Answer 8

OK! So all who think they have some revelation for muslims in store, ask yourselves these questions, may be you will get an answer to this long stretched lies:-
1. ALMOST EVERY SCRIPTURE IN THE WORLD(NOT THAT I AM ADVOCATING THAT MUSLIMS BELIEVE IN THEM) REGARD GOD AS SOMEONE WHO IS INDEPENDENT AND HAS NO SON OR PARENTS, HOW CAN THEN A RESPECTABLE PROPHET LIKE PROPHET ISA(P.B.U.H) BE CALLED AS SON OF GOD?
2. WILL ALLAH ALLOW HIS SON TO BE KILLED? IF YES, FOR WHAT..TO FORGIVE SINS OF ALL CHRIST BELIEVERS? IS IT, THEN THAT MEANS SINS OF ALL THE CHRISTIANS TO COME TILL THE END OF THIS WORLD HAVE BEEN FORGIVEN! THEN WHERE DOES THAT LEAVE THE NEED FOR A "DAY OF JUDGEMENT" AS ALLAH MIGHT AS WELL JUST THROW ALL NON CHRISTIANS IN HELL, RIGHT? ALSO, DOES THAT MEAN THAT CHRISTIANS CAN DO WHATEVER SINS THEY WANT AS THEIR SINS HAVE BEEN FORGIVEN IN ADVANCE? IS THAT JUST?

THESE ARE IMPORTANT QUESTIONS, ASK YOURSELF AND SEE WHAT YOUR CONSCEINCE AND HEART TELLS YOU.

Answer 9

No Jesus' mum and disciple John were at the cross as well as many other followers they would not have been deceived of course Jesus was raised from the dead on the 3rd day and ascended to heaven a month or so later.
but with out his sacrifice on the cross we have no salvation that is what Muslim miss out on.

Answer 10

Mohammad went to heaven on a horse. Jesus went to heaven without the help of a horse.