Did my sister deserve a cut on her lip?

Question

I was peacefully surfing the net since its a Friday, I'm tired form school. My sister bought this giant pencil and kept poking me all week with the pointy part. She does it for amusement too. Today I was sitting in my room peacefully and then she comes to my room and starts attacking me. I told her to stop, many times and that I don't want any trouble.

I then smacked her weapons out of her hands. She ran away and came back with her giant pencil... I told her stop but she didn't, so I threw this plastic boomerang thing to scare her but it hit her lip. Now she has a cut in the middle of her lip and its bleeding. Shes fine but lemme ask did she deserve it?

Thanks for reading.

I made her put ice on her lips since I felt bad accidentally hitting her.

Answer 1

No she didn't deserve a cut on the lip, but then you didn't do it on purpose either.

If a person is going to antagonize another, they need to expect the other will respond. Sometimes the response isn't what either party expects.

She wanted to get a rise out of you. Well, she got it all right.

Answer 2

YES ! that and more, if a person acts like a animal they must be treated like one, don't feel bad and talk to your parents let them know that they have a potentional physical abuser on their hands so they can get her help, she sounds weird and in need of medication, you sound cool ,keep up the good work and nice aim on that flying weapon thing

Answer 3

Yeah, I have two sisters. I know what that is like. Answer: Of course she deserved it! It's not like she's dying! I say, don't feel too bad about it, but if she does it again, ignore her, eventually she'll stop and if she doesn't, the best revenge is annoying her when her friends come over.

Answer 4

ok i mean i do think she does tho she shouldnt be messing with u when u told her to stop she didnt i fight with my brother all the time and sometimes i hit my brother and he gets hurt but like my mom always says is well he deserved it cause he should have stop when i told him to so rlly she would have never got hurt if she would have stop when u told her to stop.Just apoigize and if shes mad at you then just leave her alone for a little and sheget over it.yall are brother and sister that wat yall do yall fight get mad at each orther and then the next day everything will be ok

Answer 5

You were only acting in self-defense. Assuming you couldn't get away or lock your door, and couldn't call for help, there wasn't much you could do but fight back. She, on the other hand hasn't learned the simple principal I teach my kid every day: "Keep your hands to yourself."

Answer 6

if shes little, then no she shouldnt have got hurt you should have got up took it away and put it up. close your door and lock it. but if she older she knows better so take cae of her and tell her you are sorry but if she wouldnt have poked you that wouldnt have happend, make sure she knows it was an accsident! ether way she will get over it, just be careful big bro!

Answer 7

Yes. Pencils can be quite dangerous. In the future, maybe you should lock your door to keep the pests away?

Answer 8

She asked for it.
One can't be the aggressor for long before the shoe gets put on the other foot.
I would suggest locking your bedroom door when you are in there so she can't come in and bug you.

Answer 9

Yep she deserved it. You asked her to stop and she was being a pain in the @ss. I would still feel bad, but she got what was comming to her.

Answer 10

Well, the answer depends on a few things, such as how old she is, what you mean by 'attacking', and is she mad at you.