English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Adam and Eve sinned. God sacrifices a cow, uses its blood for their transgression, and makes clothes for them

Abraham sacrifices a lamb instead of his son

Moses builds a sanctuary in which lambs are burnt at the altar

historically evidnece indicated that early jews practiced animal sacrifice for their sins this is also in accordance wit the bible

Mary sacrifices 2 turtle doves for her sin, this in Luke

God said there is no remission of sin without blood

So, why did Jews have to commit all these animal sacrifices, if this is not true

and why does the god of islam if he is not the same require no such practice should be done for islam

but instead i can make pilgirmage to mecca and walk round the black box

Even chrisitans believe that sin is paid by blood, but throguh the blod of Jesus.

The question is, why does the god of islam if he is trhe same godf, no longer require blood either from animals or by jessu for sin,

and what was the ponit of putting the jews trhroguh it,

2007-12-07 01:54:49 · 8 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

Seeing as islam came throguh islam and judaism, what was the point of making the jews go throguh that, building a sanctuary and sacrificing lambs, ordering moses, and abraham
to scarifice lambs

accepting the sacrifice for their sins from Abel as it was an animal but not from Cain
Chrsitians don't do this as they believe only Jesus' blod is pure

so what excuse do the muslims have?

if adam and eve
abraham
moses
and every other Jewish prophet you cliam to be your own had to do it, why didn't Muhammed


Why does the god of islam no lnoger require blood sacrifices, and if he is the god of the jews why did he require ti from them?

2007-12-07 01:57:10 · update #1

It'd not about being an expert on islam, it's about looking at what God has asked us to do throughout the ages, and what circumstnaces if any caused what he asked us to do have changed

Jesus said don't stone women

Mohammed said stone them, why did God send Jesus to tell us not to stone women any more, and then send mohammed to veto it?

2007-12-07 05:11:56 · update #2

8 answers

1- I am a Muslim and although I don't really understand if you are asking or just being close-minded about Islam but I will tell you that in the pilgrimage Muslims(who can afford it) have to sacrifice sheep and distribute the meat to poor people (most of it is sent to Africa by air)
2-there is only one god who is the god of all in this universe.

2007-12-07 02:12:27 · answer #1 · answered by Don_$armad 2 · 2 0

The jews and christians were treated according to what they did in their time, and they received only part of the message relevant to their people. When Islam came, it came as a full message for whole of humanity.

Muslims go around the kaaba (black cube house) in the SAME manner Abraham did with his son Ishmael. This hajj is something Abraham did with his son and it is also the same that Adam did when he was sent to Earth after his sin.

After the hajj, Muslims sacrifice an animal and keep 1/3 of the meat and distribute the rest to others. They do this sacrifice in commemoration of what Abraham did when he was test by God of his faith by being commanded to sacrifice his only son at that time.

In Islam, one just needs to turn to God and repent and ask for forgiveness. it's that easy....

2007-12-07 03:11:49 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

no ur wrong muslims have to sacrifice twice a year and its true after ramadan and after hajj meaning before the two eids

next time stop maing false claims on stuff u have no idea about
go and get ur information straight first then ask question dude

2007-12-07 02:13:21 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

ASR
Bismillah ir-Rahman ir-Rahim
1.I swear by time,
2.Most surely man is in loss,
3.Except those who believe and do good, and enjoin on each other truth,
and enjoin on each other patience.

2007-12-08 12:08:08 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

Questioner has no knowledge of Islam but he questions why Muslims don't sacrifice animals as if he is authority on Islam.

Every Muslim who goes to perform Haj they first perform their Haj in the great open field known as AFAFAT. Here they perform two salats of afternoon and mid afternoon together being travellers and continue supplications to God for forgiveness of their sins and requesting for granting them Heaven. They all leave ARAFAT before sun set, and spend the night in the other open field at some distance known as MUZDALPHA. They perform their night prayer here, sleep, get up early morning, perform their Dawn prayer and then proceed to another place known as MINA where they have their tents to stay for two three days. Here they first sacrifice the animals for Haj. Now it is difficult to sacrifice animals with their own hands for 2 to 3 million people, so they pay for the price of animals ahead of time to people who manage all their Haj, their living, food, transportation, stay in tents in Mina, taking them back to Mecca for final Tawaf (circlying around Kaaba 7 times) and then to airport etc. They arrange Sacrifice of animals for Hajees, transport all the meat through A/C airplanes to poor countries like Bangladesh, Somalia, etc. to distribution to poor people.
Couples pay for two animals and many people pay for extra animals to be sacrificed in the name of their deceased parents also.

After Sacrifice they take their shower, wear regular outfits and next three days they go to stone to the Satans as did Prophet Abraham and his son Ismael when Abraham was taking his son for his sacrifice. For sumbolic purpose there are man made three tall pillers built where Satan appeared to Abraham and Ismael and tried to dis-suade Ismael telling him that your father is going to kill you. Ismael picked a rock and threw at Satan. Satan tried the same two more times and each time both father and son threw rocks at Satan. So at these three locations there are man made pillars are built where Hajees throw rocks at pillars to commemorate what Abraham and Ismael had to do to make Satan disappear.

Not only that Muslims sacrifice animals on the day of Haj in Mina but next day is Eidul Azha for all Muslims all over the world. People who do not go for Haj do sacrifice animals in their respective countries after they return from special Eil prayers. Those who can afford sacrifice animals give 2/3rd of the meat of each animals to other families who couldn't sacrifice the animals. This way every family cook meat on Eid Day. Never meat of sacrifice is wasteed. It is continued until finished by cooking it for following weeks whenever they wish to eat that meat. Sacrifice of animals can be done next two days also if for any reason they didn't do it first day.

Questioner thinks circling around the Kaba (Cubical building cover with Black Cover) is Haj. That is called TAWAF. It is only one part of Haj requied to do.

2007-12-07 03:15:37 · answer #5 · answered by majeed3245 7 · 0 0

Just remember that when you openly trash another's faith, you are leaving loopholes for yours to be attacked. Never forget this.

2007-12-07 09:48:23 · answer #6 · answered by Fatima 6 · 0 0

Instead of walking around a black box, try sliding in and out of a black box.

2007-12-07 01:57:57 · answer #7 · answered by officer uggh 3 · 1 2

Bismillāhir-Raúmānir-Raúeem = "In the name of Allah, most Gracious, most Compassionate".

The quality of the question is too low, you mean to say that you want blood to be sin free? what kind of a logic is this?

Murder of Jesus (pbuh) = Salvation of Christians = Injustice at its peak.

Christians chose one thing! PLZ DON’T B A GREATEST HYPOCRITE - Either u r free do to any any any crime OR u r abide to do GOOD to enter HEAVEN. And if u r free to do any crime then it means God doing injustice that someone else took ur punishment which is not God's property AND if u r abide to do good then JESUS not took ur punishment.

Christian believes is like this = If Mr. A {take him as CHRISTIANS} kills and POLICE first brutally arrest Mr. Z {take him as Jesus (pbuh)}for this crime despite clearly knowing that Mr. A did that crime & then COURT pass a VERDICT that Mr. Z should be hang till death despite clearly knowing that Mr. A killed a person. = & this is justice for CHRISTIANS.

BOTH WAYS CHRISTIANITY IS PROVED THAT IT IS NOT FROM GOD AND JESUS (pbuh) BUT FROM Saint Paul (THE GREAT MISINTERPRETER).

Do u want a "free license" to CRIME? If u? Then convert to CHRISTIANITY b/c JESUS took their punishment :^O

A SERIAL KILLER BUT A CHRISTIAN WILL GO STRAIGHT TO HEAVEN WHY B/C JESUS TOOK THEIR PUNISHMENT =D> :^O

CHRISTIANS EVEN CAN KILL THEIR PARENTS b/c JESUS TOOK THEIR PUNISHMENT. CHRISTIANS U R SO WORSE =D> :^O

SERIAL RAPIST BUT A CHRISTIAN WILL GO STRAIGHT TO HEAVEN WHY B/C JESUS TOOK THEIR PUNISHMENT =D> :^O

CHRISTIANS CRIMINALS = HEAVEN why? JESUS TOOK THEIR PUNISHMENT =D>

Is JESUS death acc. To Christians not good enough for sins that is why ppl should ask for forgiveness from God? @ CHRISTIANS

Christians murderers, rapists, dacoits, gangsters, liars, corrupts will go to Heaven =THEN IT IS INJUSTICE FROM GOD ALMIGHTY @ CHRISTIANS

If Christians murderers, rapists, dacoits, gangsters, liars, corrupts will go to hell =THEN JESUS NOT DIED FOR U @ CHRISTIANS

Christians R NOTHING BUT UN JUST PPL AND WANT GOD TO BECOME THE SAME WHICH IS NOT POSSIBLE.

WHY (GOD) WOULD NEED HIS SON OR HIMSELF OR BOTH (SINCE CHRISTIANS R MOST CONFUSED PPL) TO BE CRUCIFIED WHY NOT WITHOUT HIM HE PARDONED THE PPL?
& WHY HE SENTS US ON EARTH AND NOT SENT US STRAIGHT TO HEAVEN?:D @Christian

Why humans are here in this world, then there is no need for God to sent us on Earth, & let us wait for him to come & die for our sins. What is the reason why we are here?

"Eid-ul-Adhah is also sacrifice of animal"
The Sacrifice Of Abraham: Isaac or Ishmael(P)?
http://www.islamic-awareness.org/Quran/Contrad/MusTrad/sacrifice.html

ISLAM IS THE CONCLUSION OF THE TEACHINGS OF "ABRAHAM (peace be upon him)”, “JESUS (peace be upon him)”, “MOSES(peace be upon him)” AND EVERY OTHER REVEALED RELIGION & PROPHETS.

Towards which religion COMMON SENSE leads us?

COMMON SENSE # 1: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said like other true prophets of Allah Abraham, Moses & Jesus (pbut) etc to believe in only ONE true God & not in IDOLS or in many gODS.

COMMON SENSE # 2: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said believe in Jesus (pbuh) and his revealed book (original one which is lost) and Mosses (pbuh) and his revealed book (original one which is lost) and all revealed books and prophets otherwise u can not be a Muslim. If he is not the true prophet (MAAZ ALLAH) then why he said that believe in them otherwise u will be sent to HELL. Read “EMAN-E-MUFASSIL“ & ” EMAN-E-MUJAMEL “ 2 testify.

COMMON SENSE # 3: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) never said that he is (MAAZ ALLAH)” God “but strictly said that there is only one ALLAH (God) and no one is like him. If he is not the true prophet (MAAZ ALLAH) then why he said that? He called himself as ALLAH’s last prophet & not bragged about himself (MAAZ ALLAH) as God, as so many fake ppl did in history. Allah (S.W.T.) meaning: (the Exalted, Most Glorious) tells mankind that Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h.) is no more than a Messenger (Quran: 3/144)

COMMON SENSE # 4: Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said like other true prophets before him like Abraham, Moses & Jesus (pbut) about the JUDGEMENT DAY.

COMMON SENSE #5: If u see Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him) in pictures made by Non-Muslims, he has same kind of beard like Muhammad (pbuh) had & Muslims have, And also Mother Marry dress in pictures made by Non-Muslims is exactly 100% same as ISLAM says.

COMMON SENSE # 6:Non-Muslims say that Muhammad (peace be upon him) plagiarize the Holy Quran from the Holy Bible but this is NOT possible because Muhammad (pbuh) was not educated, then how he could do such a thing?

COMMON SENSE # 7: Another reason that Muhammad (peace be upon him) can’t plagiarize the Holy Quran from the Holy Bible is that “The Holy Bible at the time of Muhammad (pbuh) was not translated in ARABIC language then how he could plagiarize from it”?

COMMON SENSE # 8:Non-Muslims claim that Muhammad (peace be upon him) himself wrote the Holy Quran, if so then why his name comes in the Holy Quran only 5 times & Prophet Adam (pbuh) name 25 times , Prophet Abraham (Pbuh) name 63 times, Prophet Jesus (pbuh) name 25 times, Prophet Moses (pbuh) name comes 136 times, , Prophet Noah (pbuh) name comes 43 times, Prophet Hud (pbuh) names comes 7 times, Prophet Salih (Pbuh) names comes 8 times, Prophet Yousuf (pbuh) name comes 26 times, Story of Prophet Younus (pbuh) comes in 6 Surrahs in the Holy Quran & names of some other prophets comes more than the name of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), If (Maaz Allah) Muhammad (pbuh) wrote the Holy Quran then why not he used his name more than any other prophet?

COMMON SENSE # 9:If Muhammad (peace be upon him) MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he used to pray 5 times a day and conveyed the message of ALLAH that this an order from ALLAH, & in ISLAM u can’t pray without performing ablution. Why Muhammad (pbuh) used to pray? What for? For who?

COMMON SENSE # 10:If Muhammad (peace be upon him) MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he himself performed “HAJJ” which is the toughest of the pillars of ISLAM, and said that it is FARZ (Imperative) for all Muslims who have the money to afford it. For who? What for?

COMMON SENSE # 11: Why Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) strictly ordered not to do "SAJDA" before any body but ALLAH. IF he is not MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he said so? Why not he said do "SAJDA" to me as well?

COMMON SENSE# 12:If Muhammad (peace be upon him) MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he used to "FAST" for the whole month of "RAMADAN" for 29 to 30 days without a break & why he most of the time used to PRAY in TARAWEEH (long prayer) and other prayers after the FAST? for who? For what?

COMMON SENSE# 13:If Muhammad (peace be upon him) MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he used to give ZAKAAT (Obligatory Charity, Money to poor) and said that this is God’s order and every one who can afford should give ZAKAAT. FITRAA is also a God’s order and it is also giving money to poor ppl. Why he used to do that himself and said that this is IMPERATIVE for all Muslims who ever can afford ZAKAAT & FITRAA. For what and for who?

COMMON SENSE# 14:If Muhammad (peace be upon him) MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why he used to give KHAIRAT,SADQA,AQIQA,HADYA,KAFFARA etc to poor ppl which is again giving to needy ppl to gain reward from ALLAH.

COMMON SENSE#15: Even Abraham (Pbuh), Moses (Pbuh) used to dress like Muslims, cover head, beard and thoroughly covered body.

COMMON SENSE#16: There is a Quranic verse named after mother of Jesus (Pbuh), the name of the verse is Surrah-e-Mayam.If prophet Muhammad (Pbuh) is MAAZ ALLAH not a prophet then why not he named the Quranic verse name after his mother? Allah says that he choose Mary above “the women of all nations”. Why not Muhammad (Pbuh)‘s mother if he MAAZ ALLAH wrote the Holy Quran himself. (3:42). AL-E-IMRAN (THE FAMILY OF 'IMRAN, THE HOUSE OF 'IMRAN) "Behold! the angel said: 'God has chosen you and purified you and has chosen you above the women of all nations. O Mary! God gives you the good news of a word from Him, whose name shall be Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, honored in this world and the hereafter, and one of those brought near to God".

COMMON SENSE#17: If Muhammad (Pbuh) is not a TRUE prophet then why he never used alcohol and made it strictly prohibited, which is always use by humans for fake enjoyments. for whom? What for? Why?

COMMON SENSE#18: When Muhammad (Pbuh) went to MAKKAH to perform Hajj from MEDINA with all of his followers but with no arms when the ppl of MAKKAH were to HOSTILE against Muslims, for whom? What for? Why?

COMMON SENSE#19:The Prophet's wife `A'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) said, I asked, "Messenger of Allah, why do you exert yourself so much while all your sins have been forgiven?" To this he replied, "`A'ishah, should I not be a grateful servant of Allah?" (Muslim). If he maaz Allah not speaking the truth then for who he used to pray that long? what for?

COMMON SENSE#20: Muhammad (pbuh) was a posthumous & his mother died, when he was about six, then could he give unimaginable respect to parents?
(NOT EVEN UFF, TO PARENTS)
And your Lord has decreed that you not worship except Him, and to parents, good treatment. Whether one or both of them reach old age [while] with you, say not to them [so much as], "uff," (Interjection of anger, dislike, frustration) and do not repel them but speak to them a noble word. – Holy Quran 17:23
A man once consulted the Prophet Muhammad about taking part in a military campaign. The Prophet asked the man if his mother was still living. When told that she was alive, the Prophet said: "(Then) stay with her, for Paradise is at her feet." (Al-Tirmidhi) & I can quote for days about parent rights in Islam, how did he know them? Since he hardly had the love of parents.

COMMON SENSE#21: If Muhammad (pbuh) is not a true prophet then why he left the great offers offered like enemies of him can make him their king, give him all the wealth that he wants and also give him the most beautiful lady in his wedlock, but he should not propagate Islam. The Prophet replied: to his uncle "I swear by the name of Allah, O Uncle, that if they place the sun in my right hand and the moon in my left hand in return for giving up this matter (calling people to Islam), I will never desist until either Allah makes it triumph or I perish defending it." & Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), at the time of his death when he was the undisputed king of kings, he was in debt, and his shield was in the hands of a Jewish citizen of Madinah as a co-lateral for his debt. (According to Riyad-As-Saleheen, Hadith No. 504), he could have luxurious life but he left it, for who what for?
I COULD HAVE WRITE TONS OF TONS MORE COMMON SENSES BUT IF I DO THIS, THEN WHAT WILL BE LEFT FOR U TO THINK ABOUT?

Research & observations from Holy Quran & Sahee Hadith, Religious scholars like Sheikh Ahmed Deedat’s www.ahmed-deedat.co.za, Dr. Zakir Naik's www.irf.net , www.peacetv.in, Aalama Tahir-ul-Qadri, Israr Ahmed etc.

May Allah help & guide us all, Amen’.

2007-12-07 08:51:16 · answer #8 · answered by Truth Speaker by research 4 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers