Cello or Violin?

Question

Im thinking about playing an instrument. I like the cello and the violin. Im 13 years old and i have no musical talent, which one should i play? Please give me some info?

Answer 1

How do you know you really don't have any musical talent if you don't even take formal lessons for at least two years and observe your progress? You must at least try to find out.

The cello and violin are both difficult instruments and your success would depend largely on how hard you work (meaning minimum two hours practice a day) and your willingness to learn.

For all you know you may have some hidden musical talent that you simply don't know even exists. So give it a try before concluding anything. It does not matter if you choose the cello or violin. But one thing to consider, if you are not sure of pursuing a particular instrument, you might consider doing instrument rental first.

Answer 2

I've played both, but I generally stick to the violin.

Both are amazing instruments.

However, I'd suggest violin.

Cellos are very large, difficult to repair and keep up, and also hard to transport. Violins on the other hand are smaller and easier. In addition, in the beginning, your bowing arm will hurt more if you play the cello.

In addition, with the violin, you're more likely to get a prominent part in orchestras; a part that really makes a difference for a piece. There are more incredible solos, as well, for violin.

It also costs more to play a cello; between the instrument, bows, accessories, and lessons. And if you have a problem with playing, or the instrument, it'll be easier to find help if you play the violin.

All in all, I'd recommend the violin. Keep in mind, you can always try both -- and then, once you've got a taste of each, decide which you like.

Answer 3

When I first started to play, I tried the cello. I didn't have a wide enough finger stretch. Violin is closer for reaching the notes. The neck is also much smaller. It is challenging,but with practice daily you can do it. I love the sound of the cello but was unable to reach the notes. That might be your determination when making your decison to play either instrument. Usually schools will let you try one or the other to see if it works out.
Good Luck.

Answer 4

I am learning the violin but I did learn cello for six months. The cello is easier to get a nice sound from.It takes quite a while before the violin sounds nice.
But which do you really like.? Go onto youtube and have a listen to a few pieces. Better still, go to a music shop and ask if you can hear somebody play them for you. There is nothing like hearing the instrument live.
You do not know if you have any musical talent until you have been practising for a few years. I bet you surprise yourself.

PS. Don't forget to consider the viola.

Answer 5

Go for the cello. Violinists are pretty much a dime-a-dozen because it seems like just about everybody who studies music goes for that instrument. My daughter tried both violin and cello and decided that she much preferred the cello. She said that her biggest problem with the violin is the truly awkward way of holding it. The big drawback with the cello is its size but you shouldn't choose an instrument strictly because of its size and convenience. You should choose one you enjoy playing. My other daughter chose the flute because it's small and easy to carry around. However, she soon found that she hated to play it. I'm glad that daughter chose the cello. I prefer its deeper tones to the screechy sounds of the violin and it was much easier on my ears to hear her practice on it until she got to be pretty good.

Answer 6

It depends on what your goals are. If you're looking for something more versatile to do a variety of things with, then piano would be great! (my personal favorite) I don't know if you're thinking of professional music, but there's definitely a lot of hard competition for piano and violin. Harp is very unique and if you play it well, you'll probably have a lot of sweet opportunities to perform. Violin and cello are really neat if you would play in orchestras. As with sad music, the instrument doesn't matter as much as the music you choose to play. They all cost pretty much, depending on the quality of the instrument, But you'd probably be able to find a piano at a lot of community places. Harp would be pretty hard to find. Violin and cello you could rent from a local music store for a pretty good deal.

Answer 7

CELLO! I played the cello from elementary school to high school. . . it has the best sound in terms of texture. It can go as high as a violin (almost) and low as a bass. You can play a lot of music with the cello and many solos are written for them! Good luck! All instruments take patience and practice to perfect!

Answer 8

Well I suggest a piano first, I own a baby grand and I've had it for a year going on two. I love it and I could play when I was 11. I have a good ear, I just got my violin over the summer and its pretty damn hard but I suggest a Cello first. Easier to handle. I suggest a violin after you master how to hold such a thing. @.@ Its annoying but really fun to play. I am 15 by the way. :D Good luckkkk!
-Ryko

Answer 9

I suggest violin, then switch to cello after 1 or 2 years. It's easier to learn the hard stuff, then be good on the easy instrument later. I took violin in 5th and 7th grade, then switched to bass in 8th. Hope this helps. Oh and if your teacher lets the orchestra play cello music that has melody and not boring quarter notes, then I'd say go with my advice, if you want...

Answer 10

Hey! I played the VIOLA for 9 years, I LOVED IT!!! If you can't decide between cello or violin, look at the viola! It's right in between! It has a deeper, smooth sound that would make you cry! Violin was too shrill for me, cello was GORGEOUS but too sad sounding. Viola is mellow and deep and supports them both! Neither one would serve ANY purpose without a Viola! I have missed playing the viola since the 12th grade, I'm 39 yrs old, I got a viola for my 2nd anniversary wedding present! I'm going to take lessons again, and play for The Philly Philharmonic!!!! Once you play a viola, it never leaves you...
Give it a try!