English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

From a Logic stanpoint, Please prove this.

2007-11-28 19:08:57 · 18 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

18 answers

Can you prove He doesn't ? From a logic standpoint, please prove this. I can , however, recount a story/ myth ? concerning Galileo. The great man made a complete working model of our solar system, moons revolving round planets, planets revolving round the sun. All to scale and synchronized perfectly. A friend visited, looked at the 'display' with awe,"Did you make this ?" He asked." No", Replied Galileo. His friend looked baffled, "So who made it ?" He asked. "No-one ", Said Galileo, " I just came down to breakfast one morning and it had appeared from nothing." Amen.

2007-11-28 19:23:23 · answer #1 · answered by psychologist_4u 6 · 0 0

A can a bread made itself, without the Baker?

If even Alexander Graham Bell is said to be the third person who is inventing telehone but he is the one hailed as the inventor of the modern phone, therefore, will telephone exist without him? If not him then somebody else?

Can you exist without your parents?

Can a person be born and never die? A beginning without end? If so, give me one name.

Can a car last forever? Let say a Merce E200 series, will it be still there 3000 years later, and useable?

If you say nothing last foever, then the rules applies to everything. You, me, the cars, the fruits, the Stars, the Sun and this earth. If you say, as in Science, we are the matter of energy, what happens when we ceased to exist is, that ween we are transformed into something else, simply a matter of energy transfer, from life to unlife, to a state of different matter, let say dirt. Correct? Then, what is the agent of transfer? What cause it to happen that way? Why aren't we revert back to the original state of matter as in protons and neutrons and electrons?

Can a matter exist without a creator? Why is there a beginning and an end to all things. Even the Big Bang Theory have been prove that this Universe has a beginning. All the stars started from a tiny, highly compressed, superhigh density mass in a void. And suddenly, it all started outward and the created space and the universe as you know it now began its expansion. The beginning of Creation. What is that Force that held back creation, and started it forward and created other things. Do we dare to say that there is no plan as to all the thing in existence? Why is there a precise calculation of gravity pull of 9.8 m/s? Or the speed of light 3.8mil km/s? Or the speed of sound 3.5 m/s? Or the Pi constant 3.14. What are these constant stand for? What are these numbers anyway? Why do they exist in the law of the Physical World? Why did Newton say, F=MA? Why do Einstein said, E=MC2. Why is there an reaction to every action? Do matter create themselves? Does sound created themselves?

None of these above come from religious text, but the study of science. Which science will have a hard time explaning. I am a student of Physics, and I am amaze as to the precise composition that made up this earth and all the law of physics it contains. Add to that astrophysics, you will be amazed still about the vastness of this universe. There are more stars up there then the grains of sand in this whole wide world. Or should I say, in this whole tiny little earth. And it setting is not haphazard. If it was, all the planets should running against each by now. There is order and harmony in the universe, the stars in their course, the planets in theirs.
And I seriuosly think that it can't be coincidence. Everything runs like there's a plan to it, like there is a mind behind it all that control all of these things, designing the architecture. And I don't think Man can do that. When nature calls, I can't keep the s*** in, you know, I have to answer it. If i can't even control my own bowels, how can we control this universe. How can we say we are it?

2007-11-28 19:53:23 · answer #2 · answered by Quiet Within 2 · 1 0

Faith is not based on logic. It is the substance of things hoped for and the evidence of things not seen. You would not believe the proof I have. It is personal witness, of what God has done for me. But in your quest for logic, you will try and make up earthly reasons for those too. Humans are not basically logical. We live more by emotions then by logic. And I feel God in my life and heart every day. Here is logic. Is it logical to believe that we evolved, and then that evolution took a break, why did we quit evolving. Isn't evolution an on going process, aren't you are suppose to continue to evolve? If your opinion is that to believe in God needs logic, then you will never believe any proof that a Christian can give, because without seeing God, your logic is that He could not exist. so why even ask. Because your idea of logic and my idea of logic are two different things.

2007-11-28 19:28:54 · answer #3 · answered by jenx 6 · 0 0

Can you prove there is light to a blind man, or one who refuses to open his eyes, without using any testimony or anecdotal evidence from those who have seen? Can you prove there is snow on the top of the mountain to one who has lived in the desert all of his life?

Those who know God cannot hope to help by their words the brothers and sisters who have been separated from this knowledge by the mind-control of western society. The only way to reach unbelievers is to reveal the glory of God through the way we treat other human beings, and through the love and joy that shines from within us --- and if our manner and our countenance do not inspire the desert-dweller to climb the mountain and see for himself what is up there, then maybe we ourselves have not yet reached our goal.

If you still want a logical proof of God's existence, see my answer on this yahoo question page: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AlQjQk11C6eFJJWyueOKXHnsy6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20071129005429AAe5vGq

2007-11-30 18:50:08 · answer #4 · answered by Michael S 3 · 0 0

These people that blindly believe...too bad they can't think for themselves. They say, "because they believe" is an answer. They need to get into Biology and learn the facts that YES molecules can come together and form a being. Scientists now know the exact way to make life. Evolution is what changes it over the years. Duhhh!

2007-11-28 19:22:04 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

Yes ! I think I Can.

First of all , ofcourse science tells us that i.e. Big bang theory
With logic...

A 0 is always 0

To make a 0 to 1 , God is required!

God is Eternal , Something that which is Eternal Is without a beginning and without an end. So Something which is beginningless and endless doesnt need a start! So God always exists!

2007-11-28 19:18:13 · answer #6 · answered by Acid 3 · 0 2

Every canvas has a painter. The universe is metaphorically a canvas. Do people think that the perfect balance in the universe is just a coincidence. It is God that sustains it.

2007-11-28 19:33:13 · answer #7 · answered by Joe 2 · 0 0

yes , Just look at yourself . How can a human being be created uniquely , with a DNA blueprint unique to yourself only without God creating you. Although you have some genetic traits & genes inherited from your family , you are totally different from your parents.

2007-11-28 19:19:51 · answer #8 · answered by nur'ain 5 · 2 1

Someone told me, "Do you really think that a random set of molecules coming together could have create and orchestrated the things that you see around us? Everything you can see with your eyes and mind has a design."

2007-11-28 19:17:21 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

there is no real evidence either way but circumstantial evidence and indirect evidence point to no god.
Logic is confined to the realm of a natural world unless you think unsubstantiated imagination is logical for anything other than allegorical thinking.

2007-11-28 19:15:41 · answer #10 · answered by dogpatch USA 7 · 2 3

fedest.com, questions and answers