JW do you know the difference between Bloodless Surgery and Hypovolumic Shock?

Question

practical: you actually answered correctly

and yes I cant spell .. neither could Einstein so I figure I'm in good company

jeff.. you're cute I love somebody who tries to use half a fact to claim knowledge

HETASTARCH (Hespan®) treats or prevents shock, following serious injury, bleeding, surgery, or burns, by increasing the volume of blood plasma. Hetastarch is not a substitute for blood, but is for emergency situations when whole blood or blood products are not available.

The others you listed are used for hydration.. and non of these listed will solve massive blood loss .. Oxygent may ( not FDA approved ) it has the best hope.

My major point here being that when the blood issue comes up the JW use the same arguement: Bloodless surgery ... Well when your bleeding in the ER from massive trama .. that's not going to help .. and neither is any of the treatments you have listed ..

If you want to demand those treatments you will DIE ..

Tell me what is more important to Jesus Life or the Law

Mark 3-3

3And he saith unto the man which had the withered hand, Stand forth.

4And he saith unto them, Is it lawful to do good on the sabbath days, or to do evil? to save life, or to kill? But they held their peace.

5And when he had looked round about on them with anger, being grieved for the hardness of their hearts, he saith unto the man, Stretch forth thine hand. And he stretched it out: and his hand was restored whole as the other.

I' m sorry but I must say this.. Do you eat only kosher meat .. if so I'll stop this argument .. otherwise none of you follow Gods law and you are all doomed anyhow according to ACTS

Answer 1

it's so easy to talk about what you would do when one has never faced the situation.

I bet no one who's answered here has had to face this, and if they ever do, they'll be asking the doctor who holds their life in his or her hands for whatever treatment will save their life.

Answer 2

First it's hypovolemic with an e not u. Bloodless surgery is surgery without the use of blood, bleeding is controled so the use of blood is not needed, if blood loss has already happened due to an accident or other injury, there are 64 different fluids they can use to keep your volume up. Hypovolemic shock comes from the loss of too much body fluid. With bloodless surgery your red blood cell count can be raised with blood builders that don't use blood and then if some replacement fluid is needed your red blood cell count will still be good. My daughter has had many surgeries and her last one very touchy and even with a little bit lower red blood cell count she did OK without blood. It's always better to obey God than to disobey him. Nowadays many people who are not Jehovah's Witnesses opt for bloodless surgery because even surgeons recognize that patients do better without it. The blood issue was brought up to my wife and my wife asked the surgeon, can you guarantee me that I still won't die and he said no. Better to obey God and die than to disobey God and still die and not get resurrected for disobeying him when you knew better.

Answer 3

Been waiting for this. and you can't spell.

Fluids: Ringer’s lactate solution, dextran, hydroxyethyl starch, and others are used to maintain blood volume, preventing hypovolemic shock. Some fluids now being tested can transport oxygen.

And that was from 2000 so im sure they have better solutions now.

Sorry im married. I'm sure you will find a good man somewhere.

Answer 4

Yes I know the different, and I also know that you're suppose to obey Gods laws even to death.

Do you know the story of Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego? They were thrown into the furnace for refusing to worship a idol and the reason for that is because they choose to worship God and him only even in the face of persecution.

The reason why this story is relevant is because as a Christian, you're suppose to obey Gods laws even to death.

Answer 5

I couldn't add more. Well said, brothers.