Is this proof that people who have died can still hear you?

Question

well i read in a book called ...don't laugh this book actually made me cry....''Chicken Soup For The Teenage Soul'' and in a story the had in their,a girl's bestfreind had died and she did not know what to do,but to write a letter to her dead best friend and bury it with him,but she missed the burial because of traffic and schedule confilict.Well in that letter she wrote(this is only the ending of it) : ...the feel of raindrops on your face,but if you take nothing else with you,take your familys embrace.....when i die,let's go dancing in the rain.'' she then said ''smoke is faster than dirt'' and she had 2 burn the letter for it to get to him.eventually she came to burning it and let the smoke get out of her window.that night she dram about death and woke up to rain tapping on her window. Well,i thought maybe this is proof,but who knows.What do you guys think??? it makes me wonder ALOT

lol u guys have cool answers =P

OK OK OK!!! im not stupid i know people die and stay dead AND coincedences..im just asking what if??
shesh u guys actally made me laugh with all those ''common sense'' awnsers,i get the point.all i want to know is can ppl who have died still hear you?
btw no offence taken,and hopefully same 2 u guys

Answer 1

I wouldn't say this story alone would exactly constitute proof, but I would take it as a sign that someone heard her, and sent her a message. I have heard many stories of messages being received from loved ones who have passed on, so I would take it as a sign, yes. I believe I have received similar messages from loved ones who have passed on. Sure, a rainy day at that time could have just been a coincidence. But...Mother Nature works in mysterious ways.

Answer 2

You have to be kidding, right?

She burns the letter to her dead friend, and she dreams about death. Wow that is, like, so unlikely.

An then it rains at night. That again is so improbable, here it never rains at night.

Now, if she had a vision with her friend telling her where the money was buried, or something that she could not know that might be considered a form of proof.

What you have here is wishful thinking. Nothing else.

That book has the wrong title. It should be called:
"Jack Canfield's gravy train"

Answer 3

In line with islamic teaching the people who have died can still hear us.The souls of them are in the waiting room called alam barzah,before they wiil be waken up by God on the resurrection day and wiill be judged in the final and fair God's judgement..In the waiting room the souls get the preliminary rewards or punishment. .It depends on the good or bad doings during they lived on this earth..But they can not help us who still live on this earthSo they can be sent prayers by
their descendants on this earth.They could receive the rewards from the good knowledges that can be implemented for the beneficiary of humans on this earth.and their good doings which can be benefited to others such as their donation for building mosques and schools.

Answer 4

Well... that is not proof. No offense. But it rains all the time. Just because that happened and it rained that night doesn't really mean anything. I mean I'm sure it was something special to her and it made her feel better... but really... that is not proof.

Answer 5

She dreamed about what she had been thinking about, and it rained. Those two things are pretty common, they are bound to happen at the same time once in a while.

Answer 6

You must trust me on this. If the dead could communicate with the living....we'd be hearing from everyone in our lives who have ever died.... The nutcase white supremists would hear from hitler, christians would hear from jesus, moses and most of the apostles, every person who has ever lost a parent would hear from them.

It isn't true, dear. But, there is no harm in talking to someone you love who has died. Just don't spend your time waiting for a return message.

Answer 7

First of all, it is a story, which may be fictional, and written in a way to make the reader feel dramatic tension and release.

It is in no way proof as you claimed.

Answer 8

Rain. Is proof. In a fictional story.

Answer 9

That wouldn't convince anybody. But I do believe we can communicate with them in some ways. The ones we have loved can't really ever leave us.

Answer 10

Those who have died in Christ can hear us when we speak to them. They watch over us just like guardian angels do