English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

16 answers

None. The translations are NOT Allahs words. They are mans understanding and interpretation of Allahs words. If you want the actual word of Allah you will have to read the Arabic.

2007-11-15 14:12:36 · answer #1 · answered by Nunya 5 · 5 0

**********************************************************************
THE REAL TRUTH IS!!!!!!!!!
**********************************************************************
There will ALWAYS be issues with TRANSLATIONS because they are ALL faulty.
There are two things at issue here.
1. Translations give the meanings of the words from another language according to their definitions. This is often problematic because some times the meanings of words according to their definitions does not capture the SPIRIT in which they are written or spoken. It also does not include the cultural context of the words. The word cool in English is used for many reasons , not just to indicate temperature but as a form of slang. TRANSLATING the word cool 1400 years from now could easily be problematic because there is more than one definition and more than one usage.

2. Interpretations. These are attempts to relate WHAT IS MEANT by the words being used in another language. These also can be problematic because the interpretation can be misunderstood or manipulated by the interpreter.

These are not distinctions wityhout a difference, they are very important because the Arabic language(which the Qu'ran is in) is a complex one and that is one reason we muslims do not accept ANYTHING as the Qu'ran except the Arabis version.
The WORD Qu'ran means recital and when muslims say The Qu'ran we mean The Recital of God's words. These words are completely unchanged(in Arabic) since the time of their revelation. AllQu'rans (in Arabic) are word for word letter for letter THE SAME and anyone who wants to become an Islamic scholar must learn how to read and recite it , in fact MEMORIZE it in the Arabic language. Every muslim is required to recite their ritual prayers(though not the personal non-required ones) in Arabic. This means that ALL SCHOLARS will have the understanding of the meaning because they know the literal meaning of the words and the CONTEXT in which they were revealed which allows them to translate AND interpret the Qu'ran.
ANYBODY can become a scholar simply by studying.

So to answer your question fully THERE IS NO TRANSLATION AND THERE NEVER HAS BEEN OR WILL BE that is accepted by all muslims nor should there be. The only Qu'ran , by definition, is in Arabic and ALL translations and interpretations are bound to be flawed.

2. Interpretations

2007-11-15 14:36:51 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

None of them. Since the Koran is believed to be the direct word of god, as revealed to the Prophet in Arabic, it is by definition impossible to translate into another language without altering the meaning. This is why Muslims are supposed to learn the Koran in Arabic.

2007-11-15 14:13:53 · answer #3 · answered by Chance20_m 5 · 3 0

All English translations of the Qur'an are actually interpretations.

They are not, and never will be the true text of the Qu'ran because the words of the translation have been subjected to human-assisted "interpretation" en route to translation.

This is true for any language translation of the Glorious and Miraculous Qur'an.

2007-11-15 14:48:21 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 1 0

Arabic and English are two very different languages. Many of the words and syntax do not translate directly. I doubt there would ever be a 'perfect' translation everyone could agree on.
The Bible has pretty much the same probelm, hence why there is a King James 'version'.

2007-11-15 14:14:13 · answer #5 · answered by lmn78744 7 · 4 1

Have in easy terms heard approximately Pikthals and Ali's traslation, on account that Pikthals is maximum ordinarily customary you may greater constructive choose for that decision. approximately expertise Quran i might tell the only that examine it in dark and didnt have been given something out of it. how lots time do you require for expertise Engineering? What do you mean by ability of sixteen years of preparation? why dont you take a seat on your domicile and %. up scientific books to develop right into a doctor? so so as to appreciate Quran you greater constructive circulate and take a seat infront of instructors to assist you already know what it ability. to describe exact in easy terms the 1st verse, Bismillah Arahman Araheem, scholars have written books of seven and eight volumes which includes hundreds of pages and you thinks its a shaggy dog tale to appreciate Divine revelation.

2016-12-08 23:13:13 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

You can ask for explanation from the management of islamic centre or from the management of a mosque nearest to your home.I do not know exactly who is the best translator of Qur'an in your country.I think they know about it.

2007-11-15 14:34:07 · answer #7 · answered by ? 7 · 0 0

Ya gotta read it, AND understand it, in the language in which it is written. ANY translation is futile! Ya gotta walk the walk and talk the talk. Otherwise, you're just another one of them FREAKIN' INFIDELS!!! Ya gotta be EXACTLY like them, not just some cheap, english speaking translation! Ya gotta DRESS, TALK AND REFUSE TO SHAVE exactly like them or you're the equivalent of sheep poop to them! TRANSLATIONS??!! NEVER! (the embodiment of intolerance!)

2007-11-15 14:19:48 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

None of them.

The Qu'ran is only a Qu'ran when it is written in the original arabic script.

It is considered the most beautiful of all Arabic texts and truthfully looses much in translation, especially the beauty.

2007-11-15 14:11:29 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 5 3

Muslims try to protect Islam by making the Koran seem intangible and magical. If people were to read these verses, they would understand Islam's true nature.

2007-11-15 14:15:37 · answer #10 · answered by >_< 2 · 3 4

fedest.com, questions and answers