If you could take any pitcher from any ERA and put them in today's game, who would it be?

Question

I want to hear a reason for the pitcher and how you think they would do in today's game. Justify your position on this pitcher.

Thank you and I hope this brings a good conversation!

Answer 1

Walter Johnson -- just so we could finally, really KNOW, how fast he was, and see what he could do. Stats tell us a lot but there's nothing like a live performance.

Satchel Paige -- much the same reasoning. And he deserves it.

Steve Dalkowski -- to see what he could do if his elbow hadn't popped. Records galore! Not all good ones, mind you, but records nonetheless.

Tony Mullane -- to finally have that regular switch-pitcher on the mound. One inning of Greg Harris wasn't nearly enough.

Answer 2

there is greater communities than their have been many years in the past, subsequently greater domicile runs. edit: while you're speaking with regard to the HR value then it particularly is diverse. indexed right here are the HR/interest on account that 1920 (the initiating of the stay ball era) by ability of decade. 20's: 0.402 30's: 0.546 40's: 0.525 50's: 0.844 60's: 0.823 70's: 0.745 80's: 0.804 ninety's: 0.953 00's: a million.072 The been countless factors for the upward push in domicile runs the final 20 years. the main accepted factors are a) Steroids, b) growth, c) hitter friendly parks and d) livelier ball. i think of it particularly is by way of a mix of all 4. there's no longer sufficient pitching to circulate around. Hitting does not get as diluted as pitching. the sturdy hitters have become greater at bats against the weaker pitchers. they say steroids do no longer help hand/eye coordination in spite of the shown fact that it does help the ball circulate farther. multiple homers those muscle heads are hitting might have been fly outs 10 years in the past. And inspite of the reality that MLB denies it, I do think of the balls are wound tighter possibly them return and forth farther.

Answer 3

Lots of good answers so far. Paige, Guidry, and Gibson, especially.

I'd like to see how Warren Spahn would do. He could bring the heat late in the game, but pitched quite deliberately. He had a rubber arm even for his day, going into 300+ innings regularly.

Whitey Ford would be the other. He pitched HIS game whether is was spring training or Series game 7. In his prime, he was the most under rated pitcher I know of.

Answer 4

You know my answer has to be Sandy Koufax. I would like for every young fan today to have an opportunity to see who I believe was the most dominant and unhittable pitcher ever. Notice I didn't say the greatest ever or Chipmaker will be back after me. There was a reason that attendance at Dodger stadium averaged 15k more when Koufax pitched, and that reason was that every fan knew there was a possibility he would throw a no hitter. I was at the stadium when he threw his first no hitter against the Mets in 1962. Please take 7 minutes to listen to the Vin Scully call and I trust it will help you to understand what I am talking about.

Answer 5

Pedro Martinez 1998-2002: Most dominant pitcher in the game BY FAR. Pedro could control a game like I've never seen a pitcher do before and he did all this during the pre-steroid testing era.

Yes I realize it's possible that he was on 'roids himself, but I'm basing this on the assumption he wasn't.

Answer 6

I'd go with Don Drysdale. Nobody in the game today knows how to throw inside like Drysdale. I loved his theory on an intentional walk--"Why waste four pitches if I can hit him with one". I guarantee that power guys would not get their arms extended.

Answer 7

Satchel Paige. The man had a wicked variety of pitches (screw, knuckle, curve, fastball, etc) but he was able to come back and play even when he was around 50 years old. (I'm not going to look the exact age up like most people to seem smart I simply know this)

If he were in his prime and alive and pitching today ESPECIALLY w/ the knuckle and screwball - he would mess hitters up to no end. It's not like Wakefield who only has 1 pitch... Paige had 5 and a live fastball. Imagine trying to hit a 95 MPH fastball and then a 58 MPH knuckle that is 10 times better than Wakefield's?

Yeah... I thought so.

Answer 8

Josh Beckett of October 2007 and October 2003. I think he is one of the greatest pitchers in the game especially seeing how he performs in the post season.

Answer 9

Bob Gibson could throw a ball 105 mph easy. He would be better than anyone anybody in the game right now. The only pitcher who would ever compare to him is Nolan Ryan.

Answer 10

Nolan Ryan or Ron Guidrey most consistent and could pitch 9 inning. I think they would tear up the league